Brandi Carlile & Nickel Creek Cover ‘Mama Tried’ At Mothership Weekend 2024
Watch the collaborative take on the Merle Haggard favorite down in Florida.
By Andy Kahn May 13, 2024 • 2:32 pm PDT

Photo by Pamela Neal [left] / Josh Goleman [right]
Collaboration was again a constant theme throughout Brandi Carlile’s Mothership Weekend 2024. Fest performers Nickel Creek got in on the sit-in action, accompanying Carlile and her band on a cover of Merle Haggard’s “Mama Tried.”
Haggard’s song fittingly coincided with the event coinciding with Mother’s Day Weekend. Haggard released “Mama Tried” in 1968 and it soon became a staple of country music and beyond, notably played regularly by the Grateful Dead.
Advertisement
The members of Nickel Creek – guitarist Sean Watkins, fiddler Sara Watkins, and mandolinist Chris Thile – gave the arrangement of “Mama Tried” a bit of a bluegrass flare.
Watch audience-captured video footage of the “Mama Tried” collab below:
Advertisement
Loading tour dates
Loading tour dates
Advertisement
Setlist
- Oh Dear
- Looking Out
- You and Me on the Rock
- Broken Horses
- Carried Me With You
- The Story
- Fulton County Jane Doe
- I Will
- That Year
- If There Was No You
- If There Was No You
- Pride and Joy
- Drum Solo/Jam
- Before It Breaks
- Right on Time
- Mama Tried
- I Belong to You
- Closer to Fine
- The Joke
- Hold Out Your Hand
- Live and Let Die
- We Are the Champions