Brandi Carlile: The Story

By: Dennis Cook

Widely celebrated, commercially successful debuts often herald disappointing follow-ups. It's a cliché but one backed by plenty of empirical evidence. Thank our lucky stars, Brandi Carlile betters her first by a good margin on this T-Bone Burnett helmed corker.

Created using mostly vintage instruments that sparked something special in the band, The Story (Columbia) goes down ridiculously easy. It's not hard to see how VH1 has latched onto the video for the title tune, though in truth it's one of the weakest tunes here. That's not to say it's bad but it reaches for less than many other cuts. "Turpentine," the track that follows "The Story," captures the hurt and disappointment of a treasured relationship gone sideways. The opening lines are bound to hit home with anyone who's ever stumbled across their past while cleaning up:

I watch you grow away from me in photographs
And memories like spies
And salt betrays my eyes
I started losing sleep and gaining weight
And wishing I was ten again
So I could be your friend again

Carlile's phrasing recalls Patsy Cline with a greater affection for yodeling and howling, her flexible, crazy inviting voice excavating the soul and bones of each song, burrowing below surfaces and beckoning us to accompany her down.

"Have You Ever" and "Late Morning Lullaby" are the definition of irresistible, bright ribbons that ensnare one's heart and lazily shuffling feet. In these moments, Carlile and her collaborators remind one of Iris Dement's early works. "Josephine" has the insight and black and blue lilt of young Dolly Parton. Carlile echoes these greats but with her own flair. When she goes sultry on "Losing Heart" you can hear the fully fleshed woman she's growing into.

Carlile is the rare artist capable of cracking the mainstream without sacrificing substance. The Story makes clear there's depths to this young artist that'll take years to explore.

JamBase | Worldwide
Go See Live Music!

[Published on: 6/27/07]

Take full advantage of all JamBase has to offer by signing up for an account!

You'll receive

show alerts

when your favorite artists announce shows, be eligible to enter contests for

free tickets

, gain the ability to

share your personalized live music calendar

and much more. Join JamBase!



cliffcliffordjr starstarstarstarstar Wed 6/27/2007 01:09PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


Nice, DC, Nice! This chic's the bomb diggity, ya'll! Check her out!

ganjjjj star Thu 6/28/2007 07:12AM
Show -5 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
Furtado711 starstarstarstarstar Thu 6/28/2007 11:25AM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
G$Love starstarstarstarstar Mon 7/9/2007 12:02PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


Really enjoying this album, great songs, great voice, great production, much more interesting and complete from start to finish than her debut

mikonte starstarstarstar Sat 7/21/2007 09:11AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


This is a good album. The title track "The Story" is a very good song, honest, emotional and well performed. "Josaphine" is good as well. The review compares "Josaphine" to Dolly Parton, I think it is more like a Jonnny Cash type song.

I think that one of her strong suits are her lyrics with her sense of melody and song a close second.