FINDING THE BAND WITH ROBBIE ROBERTSON

  • View Comments
  • Send to a Friend

 
The songs were so disparate, from things like 'Unfaithful Servant' to 'The Shape I'm In' to 'Life is a Carnival' to 'Genetic Method/Chest Fever' to the rockabilly of 'Don't Want to Hang Up My Rock 'n Roll Shoes.' Look, any number of musicians in this day and age would kill to have written just one of those songs and have it be part of their catalogue. And they just flipped 'em out like biscuits out of an oven.

-Dave Schools

 
Photo of Robertson at The Last Waltz

I'd like to understand Dylan's influence on what would be come The Band's first record, Music from Big Pink. If you listen to the Hawk's music and then you listen to The Basement Tapes, there's an obvious evolution of The Band's sound, from the very gritty blues and R&B stuff to a more lyrically focused music. Is that where Dylan's influence on The Band is felt?


The Band by Normann Seeff
Well, it was like we were right there on our own, right there when this whole revolution was happening, and it was happening with a lot of other bands too. I think Dylan's music and his songwriting opened up a door of possibilities that you didn't have to write about the same things over and over and over again. Now you could express it in other ways. We always had a strong appreciation for the song having known some of the greatest songwriters back then, from the Brill Building and everyone that we met early on like Mort Schuman and Otis Blackwell and on and on. Ronnie Hawkins had a very strong appreciation of songs. A lot of those people out of the rockabilly world did, like Johnny Cash, Roy Orbison and Conway Twitty. There were a lot of people that were really sensitive to that. The idea that it was evolving and opening up to be expressed in a much more interesting way was a very welcome feeling at the time. There was great enthusiasm and encouragement for that growth and the expansion of the music and we couldn't help but be influenced by it.

One of the things that I've read a lot about is the influence of gospel music on you as well as the various members in The Band. When you wrote the lyrics to the "The Weight" did you envision someone akin to The Staples Singers singing on it?


The Band by Elliot Landy
Well, maybe in the back of my mind subconsciously because I was a real appreciator of The Staple Singers when all they sang was gospel music. When they became popular after that, it was really surprising to me but so deserved because I just loved their harmonies, I loved the sound of Roebuck Staples' voice. It just so happened that after we recorded Music From Big Pink, The Staples Singers were the first group to cover the "The Weight." I was completely overwhelmed and just thought how terrific how things go around like that. It was a complete surprise to me and didn't expect it in the least. I didn't have a crystal ball or even the audacity to imagine it as a possibility, you know? Then after that, Aretha Franklin covered it with Duane Allman playing lead guitar on it and I thought, "Well, maybe that song does work after all [laughs]."

Not only Duane Allman, but King Curtis played sax on it as well. That's one of my favorite Aretha tracks because it's got both of those guys on there.

That's right.


Garth Hudson
Is it safe to say that those two covers are among your two favorite instances of artists covering your songs?

They're definitely right up there. I don't think you can ask for much more than Aretha Franklin with Duane Allman and King Curtis on one hand and The Staples Singers on the other doing one of your songs.

"The Night They Drove Dixie Down" is widely considered to be among the best songwriting of your career, and it's a great example of your ability to write from the point of view of the disenfranchised. Be it the poor, the defeated Southerner, the struggling unionizers or Native Americans, you've always had this unique ability to write from the disenfranchised perspective. I'm not sure if that's the best way to characterize it but...


Levon Helm
You know, I think you are absolutely right about that, and I don't know if I've ever even looked at it that way. I wrote this song, "Acadian Driftwood," that's about when the French lost the war in Canada. These people no longer had a home there any more, so they went down to Louisiana. There was this whole colony there of people that had left Canada in defeat. I guess the same thing is true of the "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" as well, and probably so with some of the Native American things. Maybe it's just the way that I always thought of "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" was just what a profound impact that it had on me going from Canada to the Mississippi Delta and hearing all these stories in the South. I was just gathering stuff that I appreciated and thought was interesting. I didn't know I was gathering stuff for songs. I was just lapping this stuff up. I remember in the early years of being down there and hearing the expression, "Don't worry, the South's going to rise again," and it had this effect on me. It wasn't just a funny expression. There was a real truth and conviction in it and there was a sound in this person's voice that really touched me. I became such an admirer of the South and southern culture and the writers that came out of the South and the music that came out of the South and the food that came out of the South. All of these elements – the rhythm of life down there, the sound of the crickets and the thickness of the air down South – it was all just so different to me. I understood why people had an appreciation for music down there, more so than anywhere else I had ever experienced. It was like everybody was in on the joke somehow. When Elvis hit, people everywhere else went crazy but people down in the South just understood somehow. Those experiences on my first trips to the South impacted me in a way that years later, when I was sitting down to write that song, this stuff just came out. It was like all the things that I had stored in my trunk – stories and characters and stuff that I remembered from the South – came spilling out.

Is that how it often happened? Your songwriting stemmed from the fact that you were constantly on the road for so many years and absorbed all of these different characters and different stories and tales along the way?


Richard Manual
You sit down and you're wondering what you're going to write about that somebody hasn't already written about a thousand times. So, you just reach into your trunk and see what you've got in there. Because I was so young at the time – still in my teens – things made an impression upon me. When I reached in there, that's what I pulled out.

One of your other strengths as a songwriter had been your success writing for a lot of different people and different voices. From a songwriter's perspective, how does writing for you and writing for someone else differ? Within The Band specifically, did each of the vocalists represent a specific role or voice?

A lot of times, when I was writing songs, I really enjoyed the opportunity to be able to cast the person in the role of the song that I was writing. I'd be writing a song and then I would start to think what a good song it would be for Rick to sing. As I was going along, the song sounded really true to Rick's sound and what he could express vocally. The same could be said for Richard or for Levon. The song took shape and began to have a life of its own. That's when it started to make more sense to me who would sing it.

It sounds almost cinematic in the sense that it's like a director and an actor.

I remember watching those early Ingmar Bergman movies where he would use a lot of the same people playing different roles and actually relating to some of those directors like John Ford, directors that used the same people in all of his movies, where they just figured out who could play this part and who can play that part. I did relate to that because I was kind of a movie buff back then.

It's been said that your songwriting for Stage Fright shifted from the storytelling approach found on the first couple of albums to a more personal, almost autobiographical approach. I wanted to ask you if you agreed with that and what precipitated that change?


The Band by Elliot Landy
I didn't think about it that much at the time but when I look at it now, I can see that - to a certain degree – that's true. Back then, there was something that embarrassed me when songwriters wrote these songs about getting up in morning and having a glass of orange juice. It just annoyed me. I much more appreciated the storytelling of songwriting than somebody actually thinking that what they saw while walking down the street was all that interesting. It took me some doing before I felt comfortable with peeking behind that curtain to write about personal things. At the point when we did Stage Fright, what was happening within the band was becoming more personal. There were issues entering into things and they started to kind of overwhelm the music. Stage Fright is kind of an appropriate expression for what was going on with The Band at that time.

You guys were now the center of attention rather than being the backing band. I read somewhere that it was kind of the end of the ensemble era of The Band.


The Band by Barrie Wentzel
Yeah and probably by this time a certain innocence that had been there that was slipping away. Things were becoming more personally complicated for the guys in the group. At some point, there were other issues. It was no longer just about the music. There are all kinds of distractions that entered into it and things were kind of ricocheting back at us. That comes with the problems of popularity sometimes. It can spoil a good party.

Was there ever a moment after Richard Manuel's passing in 1986 that you looked back with regret for not playing with all those guys again?

No, it never struck me like that. I was just simply devastated that Richard had died. I didn't think too much about regrets because I really believe that we had done what we were supposed to do. I didn't have any feelings of regret and still don't. That's why we were able to make the decision that we drove this train all the way to the end of the line and that was it. It was time to get out and walk on our own. I was just sorry that Richard walked over the side of a bluff.

JamBase | Worldwide
Go See Live Music!

[Published on: 4/26/07]
 

Comments

cheeser420 starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/26/2007 11:58PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

The Band is eternal.

jishman starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 06:59AM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jishman

And Robbie is a bastard. Still, great interview. Now, go talk to Levon.

linsbee314 Fri 4/27/2007 07:16AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Great article Andy! It must have been quite an experience to sit down and interview a man as legendary as Robbie. I found it interesting to hear his views about how different things in The Band happened. He did sound a bit cocky at times though, like "Yea, I was going to NY anyway, so why not stop by and see Bob Dylan," as if he wasn't crapping in his pants after that invite.

Still, there's a lot of quality, in-depth discussion here. I agree with Jishman about hearing Levon's take on things too. Go up and visit him during one of those legendary barn performances!

jackstraw1984 Fri 4/27/2007 07:31AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jackstraw1984

jesus let's have one thread where no one talks shit. instead we could talk about how extraordinarily sad it is that most of us never got to hear Richard Manuel sing.

steveanderson81 starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 07:39AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

steveanderson81

Good insight. The Bands influences can be felt in A LOT of what is considered "Jam" scene music. If don't know much about them, check out their first two studio albums or the live "Rock of Ages" discs. Classic.

jonathanleeder starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 07:57AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Very good interview. I learned a ton.

jishman Fri 4/27/2007 07:58AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jishman

Jackstraw, do a little reading on the band and get someone's perspective other than Robbie's. Then you'll understand why many of us who love The Band can no longer stand Robbie and his smuggness.

mescking Fri 4/27/2007 08:43AM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

mescking

It's a shame what an ass Robbie Roberston has become since The Last Waltz. He may have been the chief songwriter but to me, he was never the soul of the band. The way he's treated his bandmates over the years, especially Levon, is disrespectful to say the least. A perfect example is from a Rolling Stone article a few years back with Levon Helm. There was a memorial service for Rick Danko and Robertson showed up in a limo, acting all pompous and not talking to anybody. It's great all the work he's done remastering and re-releasing the albums but someone should tell the guy he's not the only important member of what is one of the greatest groups of all time.

marcsmall1 Fri 4/27/2007 08:59AM
+3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

marcsmall1

Great fucking article. When I first heard "Music From Big Pink", I was in such awe and amazement that it gave me chills up and down my spine. All these guys are (North) American heroes. Even Robertson in a musical sense. Too bad Danko has passed, both him and Entwistle were huge losses to the Bass playing and Rock and Roll communities. Levon is in a class of his own.

Never gave a second thought
Never crossed my mind
What's right and what's not
I'm not the judgin' kind
I could take the darkness oh
Storms in the skies
But we all got certain trials
burnin' up inside

Don't send me no distant salutations
or silly souvenirs from far away
Don't leave me alone in the twilight
Twilight is the loneliest time a day

Billy D. Lyons starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 09:08AM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Billy D. Lyons

Great story, I really enjoyed the quotes from people like Warren Haynes and Dave Schools, it shows how influential The Band really was.
Robbie Robertson may be a smug guy, but he is not an asshole. Did anyone read the part where Robbertson was working with Ronnie Hawkins when he was just 15. Going to see people like Howlin' Wolf in some bar on Beale Street (if you don't know about Howlin' Wolf or Beale Street stop talking now!)
For anyone to experience that and then tour with Bob Dylan and the band while still in their teens would give you a perspective that many would call pompous, but can you really blame the guy.
I was born shortly after "A Coal Miners Daughter" was released, when my parents saw the film they thought Levon would be a good name to name me (Levon Helm plays Lorretta Lynnes father[the coal miner]). What a great man to be named after...

barnylee starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 09:11AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

barnylee

Excellent article. I, too, loved hearing how some of the current artists have been influenced by the Band. Thanks!

phishr82 starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 10:05AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

The Band is the best band name ever

stu62 Fri 4/27/2007 10:21AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

'Music from Big Pink' was enormously influential. It caused Clapton to break up Cream and start Blind Faith. It caused the Dead to move away from psychedelic music and move toward a new form of folk music with Workingman's Dead and American Beauty. The best rock'n'roll memoir I've ever read is Levon's 'This Wheel's On Fire.' It's a cautionary tale that should be read by every musician. There's no love lost between Levon and Robbie--mostly over songwriting credits and money.

mhc10 Fri 4/27/2007 11:08AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Probably the most influential band in modern music.
The tunes speak for itself.

SCI123 Fri 4/27/2007 11:12AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Dave can ride his bike to the byrd theatre?? damn thats suprising since he can only roll through on a bus like every 3-4 years!

SCI123 Fri 4/27/2007 11:26AM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Dave can ride a bike? thats even more suprising! HAHAHA

HOPEFULPHAN starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 11:33AM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

the band is great! who cares if the guys full of himself! trey isnt mr humble either..

guitardave starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 12:17PM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

guitardave

Too many people talk shit about musicians they've never met: "I hate Robbie, blah, blah, blah," if you are a fan of The Band and you met him, you'd cream in your Guatemala pants. Thank God he and his mates laid this incredible music on the world. He was the Kurt Cobain of the early 70s by re-directing the rock battleship.

P.S.:I once saw Dave riding a bike really fast. He was chasing a Good Humor truck. LOL!

gmoo starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 01:28PM
+4 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

gmoo

"He was the Kurt Cobain of the early 70s..."

I think I just threw up in my mouth a little bit. Last time I checked grunge was a fad, and The Band was more than a rock band. No offense to Nirvana fans, but that needed to be said. It's like saying John Bonham is the Danny Carey of the late 60's/ early 70's. I'm glad Kurt did away with hair metal, but such a comparision isn't warrented. There were so many other grunge bands that had success; I really don't understand why Cobain gets all the credit. Anyone can change the course of rock history when they (Nirvana) gets non-stop airplay on the radio and non-stop press and publicity. At least you didn't compare Robbie to Axl Rose :) Great story and read. Thanks jambase.

lovejahlive Fri 4/27/2007 01:45PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

lovejahlive

Great story.
In response to an earlier comment:When you're a kid,which is what Robbie was at the time,anything seems possible.
Hell,he hit the road and fulfilled his dreams of playing the music that he loved at an age when most of us didn't even have a dream.
That said,Robbie is further confirmation that "money is the root of all evil.."

21mmer Fri 4/27/2007 02:46PM
+6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

21mmer

perhaps the best/most-amusing moment caught on film in rock history is when van the man sings 'caravan' on the last waltz. i can't get enough of those karate kicks.

assafjaffe starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 03:03PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

assafjaffe

Great article, good comments. Props to everyone who brings up the importance of getting the full story. Robbie is a genuis and deserves respect. I do have some sore feelings that he broke up the band against the wishes of all the other members, that he blew them off at the rock and roll hall of fame induction and ways he has been dismissive of the talents and hard work of Richard, Levon and Rick. Robbie has done very well for himself, I hope he can take the time to consider where he would be now if not for all the work his BAND Mates put in. Read Levon's book. It's one sided but may help shed some light onto some of the angry and negative comments people made. Robbie wrote most of the songs. With the help of three amazing singers he helped create in my opinion The Greatest Band in History. Respect to James Robert Robertson for that.

He killed the Band on his own. I'm sad about that and I know it really hurt Richard and Rick the most. May they rest in peace.

Love to all the guys in the Band. Thanks for everything

mhc10 Fri 4/27/2007 03:50PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Don't even put Robbie Robertson and Trey in the same breath.
Trey wishes he could have an ego like Robbie.
Robbie was the man. It's a shame how it all went down between he and Levon though.

SCI123 Fri 4/27/2007 03:52PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

"P.S.:I once saw Dave riding a bike really fast. He was chasing a Good Humor truck. LOL!"
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

manbearpig starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 05:43PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

manbearpig

THe band is THE BAND
schools chasing aan ice cream truck hahahaha
you just made my day

dannymo starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/27/2007 06:52PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

the Band-timeless beautiful soulful music Rick Danko-missed dearly and never forgotten Robbie- master of his craft& one giant PRICK

corocker Sat 4/28/2007 01:32PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

why the hell didn't they talk to Levon? This is disrespectful and makes no sense.

crowesfan starstarstarstar Sat 4/28/2007 04:49PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

The Band is one of the most underrated bands of all time. If you haven't read Levon Helm's book This Wheel is on Fire then you should because it is great. It really lets you into the world of The Band coming from the point of view of one of the most crucial members. He is also from Arkansas and so am I so that is pretty cool. No famous people or good musicians really come from this shitty ass state. I also agree that Robbie Robertson is a prick. He took credit for a lot of their songs that he shouldn't have. The rest of The Band also hates The Last Waltz because there is too much focus on Robbie. Now I'm not saying i don't like Robbie, he is great but he should have stayed with The Band.

theragman starstarstarstarstar Sat 4/28/2007 05:03PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

best band ever.

alabamaslamma starstarstarstarstar Sat 4/28/2007 05:24PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Corocker, did it occur to you that Levon might not have returned a number of phone calls and e-mail messages? Or that Garth might have done the same?

Going off half-cocked, accusing people of disrespect is, err... disrespectful.

Tell you what, I'll keep checking back to read your interview with all three surviving members of The Band. Looking forward to it.

dannymo Sat 4/28/2007 06:17PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Crowesfan,
don't hate on your home state. Col. Bruce and BillyBob Thorton are from there and you seem like a level head.

alabamaslamma Sat 4/28/2007 07:37PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

You can add Sister Rosetta Tharpe, Luther Allison, Johnny Cash, Al Green, CeDell Davis, Jimmy Driftwood, Louis Jordan, Son Seals, Roosevelt Sykes, Jimmy Witherspoon and Fred Tackett to your list of Arkansas musicians.

AdCo Sun 4/29/2007 04:58AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

the band is one of the greatest ever

last time there was a band article on this site i posted this link - the article is entitled "do it, puke, and get out" by levon helm

its his take on the last waltz, and i think it would do alot of you really well to see how robbie treated levon during the last waltz.

while he was a great songwriter, the fact is that robbie broke up the band. he was most certainly not the soul of that group of musicians.

http://jmdl.com/library/view.cfm?id=1217

another fun fact, anyone notice how in the entire last waltz, scorsese has muted robbies mike? his voice sucks compared to the incredible pipes that levon, rick, and richard had.

mad love to the band

richard and danko - RIP
levon - stay healthy
garth - be garth

mgizmo starstarstarstarstar Sun 4/29/2007 09:41AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Big thanks to Jambase for printing this fascinating article! More stuff like this please.

Maybe next we can do Dylan and see what all the haters on Jambase will say about that.

I am inspired to go and read Levon's book now. I already knew the consensus opinion of Robbie before I got to the opinions here and I was totally expecting the haters to have a field day talking shit about him. Special thanks to him for showing up and doing the interview which was great.

AdCo Sun 4/29/2007 10:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

i love the band. robbie ended the band. this makes me sad. anyone else hating?

JRyan starstarstarstarstar Sun 4/29/2007 01:56PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Excellent article! The only thing that puzzles me is why someone from Tea Leaf Green (IMO, the most overrated band in the scene) would be asked to comment on something as influential as The Band. But, I guess a younger perspective is interesting to some. Thanks for the piece!

corocker Sun 4/29/2007 02:26PM
0 Votes