Home › Venues › Mattingly’s Tavern Mattingly’s Tavern Tickets Buy tickets for concerts at Mattingly’s Tavern in Florida, NY. No Upcoming Events No upcoming events scheduled at Mattingly’s Tavern. Please contact us with any corrections. Hotels & Lodging Near Mattingly’s Tavern About the Venue Mattingly’s Tavern At-a-Glance Address16 N Main St.Florida, NY 10921United States Map & Directions Advertisement