Words by: Craig Willard

The Black Crowes :: 09.12.06 :: Lupo's Heartbreak Hotel :: Providence, RI

The Black Crowes
Chris & Rich Robinson
The Black Crowes continued their year-and-a-half-long run by making a return appearance at Lupo's Heartbreak Hotel in Providence, RI. The previous show found them gearing up for a monumental New Year's Eve show in none other than Madison Square Garden, capping what many said was the finest tour and the sweetest sets the band had spun since inception. This time, however, found them on the heels of uncertainty, with two benchmark members, Marc Ford and Ed Harsch, both leaving due to personal reasons. Of course, speculation has run rampant as to the nature and cause of the departures, nowhere more so than on the band's own fansite, Amorica, where an editorial view of Virtue & Vice turns into a rant about Kate & Owen, to how much a "fan" hates "Remedy" as fast as you can think of the words to "Conspiracy."

Lupo's marked the fifth show of the Fall leg and was set up as a defining gig for the current lineup, as two of the last four shows were played as "greatest hits" sets in venues with casual fans, while the other two shows found the band working with training wheels. This two-set stand was far from disappointing. With no opener on the bill, the band launched into the three-hour tryst with "Halfway to Everywhere," moving swiftly into a nice jam that led into the rocking "Black Moon Creeping." This was followed by another song, "Hotel Illness," off their defining album Southern Harmony and Musical Companion. Following the Companion selections was "Hi-Head Blues," off of the dark horse favorite Amorica. The boys then dug deep with a trio of covers: the Grease Band's "Let it Be Gone," "Long Black Veil," and Free's "Ride a Pony." In getting back to BC basics, they closed out the first set with a solid "Twice As Hard" > "Thorn Jam" > "Thorn in My Pride," which featured a hard-hitting Gorman solo to wrap it up.

Chris Robinson by Darren Ankenman
The missing spots of Ford and Harsch have been rounded out by Paul Stacey and Rob Clores, respectively. Stacey is no stranger to the band, having played in Chris Robinson's side project from a few years back, New Earth Mud. Before being tapped to fill out the stage-left guitar spot, he had already been working with the Crowes on their upcoming studio album. It should be noted that also playing in New Earth Mud was Stacey's brother Jeremy on drum kit, so if Steve Gorman decides he needs a break next, that base is covered. Name possibilities could be "Dirty Crowes," "New Black Earth," or even "Soiled Simpatico." Clores has also fielded some of the Robinson Brothers' time, playing in the aptly named Rich Robinson Band. They both held their own, probably much to the chagrin of nay-sayers on the message boards. Granted, Stacey was taking cues from Rich, but the music still flowed with the ease of someone who had been in the trenches much longer than a few shows. Rob's keys were not really showcased, but played more of a support role.

Rich Robinson by Darren Ankenman
The second set kicked off with another tune from Amorica, "Wiser Time." Stephen Stills' solo "Song of Love" came next, with Rich breaking out a sweet blonde Gretsch hollow-body. If I remember correctly, he also took some licks off a Rickenbacker, which he no doubt stole Saturday from Tom Petty's gear trailer when TP wasn't looking. "Welcome to the Goodtimes" trotted out next, perhaps saying that the Crowes were still a force and enjoying the ride, despite the circumstances from the past month. Chris Robinson even made a crack about how much fun they were having, which was felt throughout the night. Continuing with the covers, "Tough Mama," a cut off Dylan and The Band's Planet Waves, was tossed in. The only new material played was "Cold Boy Smile," which was received rather well. It has made a few appearances this past Spring and Summer, so it is gradually becoming more familiar. Hopefully, this song will make it on the upcoming album, given it doesn't turn into a Chinese Democracy.

The Black Crowes
Going into the last turn, "Soul Singing" was fully charged, rousing the crowd with its guitar interplay between Stacey and Rich Robinson, who then took over vocals for a rendition of Pink Floyd's "Fearless." Going back to the Amorica well, "Nonfiction" got the loyal followers worked up, while chart songs "Jealous Again" and "Hard to Handle" were the closers for the casual attendees. It should be noted that the backup singers really add so much to the ensemble on stage. Charity and Mona have hung in there since almost the beginning, even as Charity lost her son this past summer. The community came together, raising a donation in her son's name for First Candle, which is a national SIDS alliance. After a quick off stage breather, encore time was at hand, with one more lil' taste of freak & roll for the night being given in the form of Fleetwood Mac's "Oh Well."

Many expected this tour would be cancelled. Most bands would have hit the skids in having to fill not just one, but two key members' holes. The Black Crowes have not only risen to the occasion, but they have taken it head-on by not playing it safe with well-traveled songs that have been deemed "greatest hits" songs by fans with questionable allegiance. As they make their way across the Midwest in support of a rarities album and vault DVD, you can count on the fact that these Crowes are not lost.

JamBase | Providence
Go See Live Music!

[Published on: 9/14/06]

Take full advantage of all JamBase has to offer by signing up for an account!

You'll receive

show alerts

when your favorite artists announce shows, be eligible to enter contests for

free tickets

, gain the ability to

share your personalized live music calendar

and much more. Join JamBase!



cocheese Fri 9/15/2006 08:13AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


Relix reported the other day that G-Mac's agent reportedly contacted the Crowes about him joining the band. I haven't heard anything more. That might work, but it doesn't seem to fit to me.

johnnyroad Fri 9/15/2006 08:34AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

gmac was in jackson the other night and denied those rumors, but i disagree....think that would be a great fit.

bigrivermusic starstarstarstar Fri 9/15/2006 11:18AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Apparently the Gmac rumor was started by some folks with nothing better to do from Jambase posted the article and then quickly removed it. My opinion is that gmac would be a better fit for the Crowes than with WSP. I do thank George for helping to keep the Good Ship Panic afloat during some trying times. I saw 50 or so Panic shows with George and he was really coming into his own and didn't deserve the flack that he caught for taking over a difficult spot to fill.

derreck starstarstar Fri 9/15/2006 01:37PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


I agree. Gmac would fit nicely into the Crowes.

johnnyroad Fri 9/15/2006 01:59PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

well said big river. i have listened to george since the beanland days...super guy with super talent. i wish nothing but the best for him. he caught way too much undeserved heat. he came in and helped the boy's when they needed him most and got shitted on in return. just my opinion obviously

ladalmond starstarstarstarstar Fri 9/15/2006 06:23PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Great Band, and Paul Stacey can cut some heads. i love the crowes because they are still playing real good music, they dont try and follow the times, i guess that's why they have been around 15 years, while most bands everybody listens too will be gone by next year hopefully..

beadiamondsomday starstarstarstarstar Fri 9/15/2006 09:58PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


gmac would be cool. i will support george in any thing he does, it would be a goood fit, who knows though

‹^› ‹(•¿•)› ‹^› {¬¿¬} starstar Mon 9/18/2006 07:59AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

‹^› ‹(•¿•)› ‹^›      {¬¿¬}

haha too late jambase.. now we all think gmac should be in crowes.. he may be called deedle dee in his days of panic, but I have seen him dig deep on a barstools on 4-20-05.
Good luck to GMAC.. and well.. lets see what the crowes do..

good comment bigriver.. peace ya'll

STEG187 Mon 9/18/2006 08:10PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


This review is laughable. You clearly have an agenda in regards to "selling" the new version of the band.

The message boards are DEAD ON! This band is not really The Black Crowes without Marc Ford (or Weird Ed!). They can play the "songs" all they want, it ain't the real deal!

It was, is, and will ALWAYS be FORD!

and the true Black Crowes site is


STEG187 star Mon 9/18/2006 08:11PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!



moremiles Tue 9/19/2006 09:42AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

it's so funny to me that soooo many people think that Marc Ford is the black crowes...Marc Ford is a great guitar player and that's it...He didn't write on very many songs if any. I have seen them tons of times over the past fifteen years, in every form of the band. It's a kick ass show regardless who plays w/ them..Ed Harsh is way more important than Marc, trust me....For all you haters, just go find another band, and shut the fuck up. Yer not real fans that the backlash begin....

pabloescobar starstarstar Mon 9/25/2006 01:41PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

gmac in the crowes will send them into a sprial downwards faster than he did with panic. without marc ford the crowes are a shell of their former selves.

johnnyroad Tue 9/26/2006 11:08AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

keep the gator lines to a minimum pablo...obviously your hittin it way too hard

kellerisafeller Wed 10/18/2006 12:43PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


i love the crowes no matter what they are what keeps real rock alive today