The Join, Steel Train, Alta Mira | 12.28

Words by: Josh Potter | Images by: Andy Hill

The Join, Steel Train, Alta Mira :: 12.28.07 :: Revolution Hall :: Troy, NY

The Join :: 12.28.07
For music lovers who know that you don't need a guitar for a good time, this post-Christmas, pre-NYE gig with The Join was a veritable wet dream. Two hours before show time, the giddy array of drums and keyboards Marco Benevento and Joe Russo (Benevento/Russo Duo) had amassed next to those of Darren Shearer and Jamie Shields (The New Deal) had set the crowd to a healthy titter. A boxy, two-level room, Revolution Hall can feel like the setting for a cage match, and with two keyboard/drum duos set up in perfect symmetry, it didn't seem entirely inconceivable that the venue would actually provide an announcer to explain the rules of engagement.

Instead of an announcer, two opening acts graced the tiny vacant sliver of stage. Local favorites Alta Mira started things off with a collection of proggy pop-songs. Odd time signatures propelled (and sometimes beguiled) melodramatic vocals with obvious nods to both Pearl Jam and Incubus. Rising indie-tweakers Steel Train piled in next and proceeded to hit hard with their uber-infectious brand of mop-top-rock. Jersey to the core, the Boss clearly had their backs, even when U2-esque intros gave way to Strokes-style abandon. Most surprising were their lengthy, driving, Band of Gypsys conjuring blues assaults.

Jamie Shields - The Join :: 12.28.07
The Join is a sporadic project put together by Shields and Shearer, born in the absence of New Deal bassist Dan Kurtz. The rotating cast of support musicians has featured members of The Disco Biscuits, Umphrey's McGee, STS9, The Duo, and Brother's Past. As Shearer would later elucidate, this mini-tour was the first time these four artists had played together since their performance at this past summer's Re:Generation Festival, and, like always, the material was entirely off-the-cuff. It all started with a bass groove from one of Shields' synthesizers. Without hesitation, Shearer followed his bandmate's lead and launched a hallmark house beat that lasted, through various incarnations, for 45 minutes.

The first set began with intense communication between like instruments. Shields would offer a motif while Benevento would ease his way in with ambient, delay-affected Rhodes, hovering organ, and circuit-bent gadgetry. Shearer began in telepathic fashion, as the template was his familiar, high-octane live-house. While Shields gestured changes to Benevento, Shearer signaled instructions to Russo. Russo was reticent at first, unsure of his place within the mix. With Shearer skating about on the high-hat and snare, Russo pulsed away at his floor tom and occasionally added tinny accompaniment on a metal salad bowl he had mounted next to his snare. Sporting gents, the band would occasionally cut away to feature Russo alone, in compensation for his reserved role early on. But slowly, the formula was established. As Shields' motifs were handed around from keyboard to keyboard, the low end gave way to the thunderous drum line. Pretty soon full genres were being passed back and forth, with house beats birthing post-rock celebrations, and organ-driven soul grooves building into reggaeton. Before the first set came to a close, it was clear that this was more than a celebrity jam or a battle of the bands. And while traces of the Duo's "Hate Frame" might have been evident at times, this was a pure "mayhemical, havocal groove" as Shearer put it.

Marco Benevento - The Join :: 12.28.07
Set break appeared to be just the thing to reboot The Join's chemistry. Shields started with markedly more patience, and while acute listening eliminated the necessity for hand-gestures, a wholly organic set emerged. Russo stepped up from the get-go, forcing the quirky, off-kilter grooves that are his bread and butter into Shearer's techno traffic. The result was an athletic responsivity from both drummers. Benevento favored his organ from the start, working his left hand in counterpoint to Shields' robotic synth lines. As the first piece fizzled, Benevento dug in on Rhodes, launching a climactic Duo-esque coda that set the standard for the rest of the show and earned the admiration of his fellow musicians.

The set continued with an upbeat, melodic theme. But in symphonic fashion, the music-box keyboard tones grew dark and Shields drove a sci-fi, space-rock groove into nebulous territory. While ideas in the earlier part of the show were addressed and abandoned, here full songs were being fleshed out on the spot. Through sheer repetition and responsivity, a repertoire-less band was amassing a catalog. All had become loose and intuitive. After one groove dissolved into a drum duel, an abstract Led Zeppelin romp was enough to remind listeners that these guys weren't, however, flying entirely without a net. Shields did, after all, substitute for Benevento during the Bustle In Your Hedgerow set at this summer's Camp Bisco.

By the end of a lengthy encore, marked by Russo's clowning and Shields' beaming contentment, the results had come in: both guitars and heroes were obsolete here. While hope for a future New Deal tour is not entirely grim and the likelihood of Join/Duo collaborations is decidedly modest, this was a show of music born in the moment - something bound to erupt amongst musicians who know how to make it happen.

JamBase | New York
Go See Live Music!

[Published on: 1/3/08]

Take full advantage of all JamBase has to offer by signing up for an account!

You'll receive

show alerts

when your favorite artists announce shows, be eligible to enter contests for

free tickets

, gain the ability to

share your personalized live music calendar

and much more. Join JamBase!



edgeit starstarstarstarstar Thu 1/3/2008 06:22PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

saw them new years @ highline. fucking PHENOMENAL, absolutely blew my mind.

minguslax35 starstarstarstarstar Thu 1/3/2008 07:04PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I was at this show and these guys kicked serious ass all night long. Steel train was also a good surprise for me. I'd never heard of these guys and while it wasn't the genre I came to the show for, I throughly enjoyed their sound. Great article.

tourfan starstarstarstarstar Thu 1/3/2008 08:17PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Really great review JP. As a fellow scribe and contributer here at the base, I know how hard it is to review a show without a setlist. You offer a clear understanding of what kind of music was produced this night. This is a fine example of music criticism. And I really love Rev Hall. Have a burger and Brew next door at the pub. Peace.

nuke_ticketbastard star Fri 1/4/2008 05:34AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

i went to see the join at sonar club in baltimore last weekend. i must say i did not know what to really expect. i def did not realize it was going to be to drum kits and two keyboard setups! so i went with the highest of expectations being that i have read aLOT of good stuff about the duo. then when they still hadn't hit the stage by eleven or twelve i thought "okay this place is gonna explode" . of course by this point i had seen the huge array of drums and keys filling the stage , but there was also a guitar and a few mics.... anyhow they proceeded to finally come out and played for i guess about 1 and a half hours? i thought they were def good at what they do.... but it just doesn't get me movin... i guess i really was just ignorant to what they were all about , my mistake! no vocals and no guitar , save for some guy who set in for 1 song , not sure who he was... i don't know it really just seemed to go nowhere.... like i said i think they were good at what they do , but they just don't do anything that stood out. anyhow my mistake it won't happen again... maybe i am just getting old but no vocals and no guits , all trance stuff.... not for me.

flyercup10 starstarstarstarstar Fri 1/4/2008 08:46AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Did anyone catch that "Becky" towards the latter half of the second set? Unbelievable! Please tell me there is a recording of this show...

ao1 starstarstarstar Fri 1/4/2008 10:05AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!


Yea.....I saw these guys at the paradise in Boston...What can I say....they haven't been playing together for long and it shows...The concert itself was a very good time...High energy for the most part. Each individual musicians skills shine at one time or another and when everyone is feeling the groove the whole place is ripe with energy. I recommend them to anyone wanting to dance and not analyze them for the complexity of their music.

The1AndOnlyDJCT starstarstarstarstar Fri 1/4/2008 10:33AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I saw them at the Highline and they fucking blew my mind, it was unvelievable! And kizzy, the guitarist I think you're talking about is Tom Hamilton from Brother's Past and American Babies. He sat in with them at the New Years show too and it was ridiculous! Let's see more of The Join soon please!!

lemonwheel44 Sun 1/6/2008 06:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

i too was saw the join nye at highline. the show was awesome but the crowd blew. saw a fight front row and this guy and girl dry humping during 2nd set. highline security/employees were dicks. weak sauce new york city, weak sauce. ill never return to the highline.