fatchance.....just to play devil's advocate: you say that for "adults" it is boring to hear something recreated that has already been done, yet you have 4-5 tribute/cover bands listed under your favorite artists (cubensis, phix, bustle in your hedgerow, etc.). does this not strike you as somewhat hypocritical?
to the general audience......nobody plays floyd better than floyd (not UM, not claypool, not these guys), but i think we all know that the prospects for a "floyd" project(or even gilmour or waters solo) are slim-to-none. personally, i support any talented artists that want to keep the music of floyd alive and well. the video looks and sounds like these guys can hold their own to any of the other bands know to cover floyd.
and, yea, the frog brigade covered a lot of floyd.......8 years ago. now, the frog brigade is no-more (unfortunately) and claypool hasn't done anything that has captivated me for years (except the primus set at rothbury '08).