UNCOVERING MATISYAHU

  • View Comments
  • Send to a Friend

 
That process - the commitment and devotion one must undergo, study and live - is a dangerous thing. I am lucky, and happy, to have come out the other side in this place. But the more I study, I read, I listen, I learn.

-Matisyahu on his transition to the Chabad-Lubavitch Hasidic community

 

Miller was at a crossroads. Done with Phish and in failing health, he returned to White Plains, where he promptly chopped off his dreads. His parents sent him to an Outward Bound-style "Wilderness" program in Bend, Oregon. Upon completion of what Miller calls this "rehab situation," he rekindled his musical ambitions, filled with the experiences and emotions of the last half-decade.


Matisyahu by Jake Krolick
"There was a coffee shop in town where I met a guy with dreadlocks who played guitar, and every Thursday we played there," he recalls. "Young kids started bringing turntables. I would wear an Israeli flag like a turban and we'd do crazy hip-hop chanting. And then boom, people started coming in for that. We ended up putting a band together. Back then I referred to myself as MC Truth, but my rhymes were far from spiritual content, more like a 'Learn Yourself' type of approach. Definitely crucial times for me."

Matisyahu returned to New York two years later to attend college at the New School. He began frequenting the Carlebach Shul on the Upper West Side, during this time forging a close bond with Dov Yona Korn, a Lubavitch rabbi he met in Washington Square Park.

Matisyahu bought a PA system and started collecting instrumental reggae tapes. I tell him sometimes his singing reminds me of one of my favorite artist, Sizzla, a pioneer of conscious dancehall deejay styles. Startled, he responds, "You can really hear that? I totally studied Luciano's flow and melody, and Sizzla's flow, energy, high notes, and stuff."

"Lots of the reggae artists are called conscious and the words are about their Lord," continues Miller. "I respectfully will not speak His name, but they're talking about G-d. So many roots lyrics were taken or adapted from Old Testament scripture. I was able to find my culture AND my own true identity in Judaism inside these inspirational songs. I hold onto the truths," he laments, somewhat subconsciously defending the accusations of his affinity for reggae music being insincere.


Matisyahu
However, he does mix in contemporary emceeing and especially beatboxing, which has taken a prominent role in his live show. It's a talent he likes to incorporate, albeit sometimes a bit inappropriately, much to the chagrin of reggae purists. In addition to the boom-bap of his hip-hop roots, he's woven the traditional Hazzan-style of Jewish Cantors and Hasidic Rabbis into his act.

Matisyahu's music is a bewildering synthesis of Bob Marley and Shlomo Carlebach merged into a flawless flow of Torah-inspired rhymes. It's the cultural fusion Matisyahu is encouraging - a new musical medium fusing the historically insular Orthodox Jewish community with the world of nightclubs, secular fans, and marketing ploys - that really sets him apart. It also makes him a larger-than-life persona that's willing the Americanized Jewish youth back towards The Word and principles dictated to the Children of Israel from their monotheistic G-d through the teachings of Moses, Kings Solomon and David, and later reinterpreted by Rabbis like Menachem Mendel Schneerson, and Carlebach.


Matisyahu by Trevor Pour
Initially, Matisyahu found a perfect partner in JDub Records, a young nonprofit organization whose mission is to promote Jewish voices in popular culture. Among JDub's other artists are the Yiddish-rapping hip-hop producer So Called, the Jewish indie-folk band Black Ox Orkestar, and punk klezmer group Golem. Executive Director Aaron Bisman met Matisyahu four years ago as Bisman was finishing up in the music business program at NYU and DJing with an electro-acoustic Jewish soul band. JDub was in its embryonic stage - as were Matisyahu's skills on the mic - and the two made a commitment to work together as they grew.


Matisyahu by Jake Krolick
Unfortunately, as Matisyahu gained international prominence and became a star, his interests and the direction of his career changed. Bonnaroo with Trey Anastasio, Live at Stubbs' monster single/MTV video "King Without a Crown," and a cultural phenomenon sweeping the Jewish youth across the globe can do that to an artist.

The breakdown of his relationship with JDub was tumultuous, although Matisyahu did not speak on the subject during our brief conversation. The Internet message boards on JDub's site and other Jewish youth online communities have been bubbling with friction over how to perceive this abrupt change in representation, foundation, as well as possibly philosophy. It's as if Matisyahu was careful to steer the dialogue away from this clearly uncomfortable situation.

However, Matis did drop a few red herrings that said a lot while saying just a little. When we talked about his sharp turn toward orthodoxy, he at first was gleeful about recounting the beginnings of his mammoth spiritual quest. He told me about one night where instead of sitting on his NYC rooftop and blazing a spliff, as was his custom, he instead spoke to the Lord for the first time as an adult. The conversation was awe-inspiring, tremendous. "The power of this closeness to Him, was...," he says, his charged voice trailing off to a mumble.

Maybe most interesting was his description of his transition into the Crown Heights Chabad-Lubavitch Hasidic community. On the heels of the separation from his label/manager/agent, he chose his words carefully. "That process - the commitment and devotion one must undergo, study and live - is a dangerous thing. I am lucky, and happy, to have come out the other side in this place. But the more I study, I read, I listen, I learn." Again the enigma's voice tails away in a whisper.


Matisyahu
Is he for real, though?

The fans and charts, outside of Jewish cultural circles, seem to think that indeed he is. Both of his records - Live at Stubbs, and his studio debut Youth - have gotten heavy airplay on college radio and placed on the Billboard charts. His music has been received seriously, and often warmly, in the mainstream pages of Rolling Stone, Riddim, Vibe, though he's been slammed by noted critics like Kelefa Sanneh of The New York Times.

Recently Matisyahu stopped by Club Midway to rock with Big Apple drummer sensation the Adam Deitch Project, which apparently unveiled some sinister flows and vicious freestyling, chatting, and beat-boxing. The singer also has a few dates lined up around the holidays. We can only wait and see what the messenger brings forth with future offerings.

JamBase | New York City
Go See Live Music!

MATISYAHU TOUR DATES
12.14 | Theater of Living Arts | Philadelphia, PA
12.17 | Hammerstein Ballroom | New York, NY
12.19 | Hammerstein Ballroom | New York, NY
12.20 | Avalon | Boston, MA
12.21 | Lupo's Heartbreak Hotel | Providence, RI
12.31 | House of Blues | Chicago, IL
03.09 | Langerado Music Festival | Sunrise, FL
03.10 | Langerado Music Festival | Sunrise, FL
03.11 | Langerado Music Festival | Sunrise, FL

http://www.matismusic.com/

[Published on: 12/14/06]


12All

 

Comments

lovemusicfood star Thu 12/14/2006 04:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Funny no mention of him fighting with bandmates over money... Seen him perform, and it's totally a gimmick... Seen local beat boxers that are way more impressive and no fake religion thing. The reason it's fake is that the religion itself is not real.

mr2bits Thu 12/14/2006 04:26PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I've got nothing against Matisyahu or his fans.

That said, is this story really NEWS to anyone on this site? I'd venture to say that most of the readers on this site are already familiar with his personal story and what he stands for. Some think he's a gimmick. Some think he's the real deal. Regardless of the opinions of the Jambase community, I think its safe to say these opinions have already been formed for quite some time now.

When I read stories like this, I'm left thinking "Gee I wish my favorite artist had Matisyahu's connections. If only my favorite artist were signed by a Sony subsidiary, maybe they'd appear on Jambase more often"

There has been a lot of debate lately on the direction this site has taken. At first I dismissed it, as elitism by site groupies. This article has made me take notice.

If you guys at the top want to report on an upcoming Matisyahu TOUR, i'm all for a world with more information. This on the other hand is pandering to big money, plain and simple.

matttroche Thu 12/14/2006 04:30PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

matttroche

yo love music food, how about a little religious sensitivity.

ĂȘtre starstarstarstarstar Thu 12/14/2006 05:25PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

ĂȘtre

Congratulations to "lovemusicfood' for being the first BIGOT to post on Jambase. I suppose that the Holocaust was not real either? Why don't you go fellate David Duke?

jerryil star Thu 12/14/2006 05:44PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jerryil

If this WAS all about religion, would the artist not donate ALL PROCEEDS back to his church (or place of worship)? Is it in the name of God, or money? I wish jambase would do an article on Amy Grant and the Rev. Bill Grahm too.

lovemusicfood star Thu 12/14/2006 07:46PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

The Holocaust being real and real people dying has nothing to do with some guy representing himself as holy behind some ideology that only has meaning in his head. Looking forward to the next article on Creed.

Lupinemutton star Thu 12/14/2006 08:16PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Lupinemutton

Jerryil, you're an idiot. Jews don't go to church. They go to Shul or Sinagogue or Temple.. but not church. Also, I happen to know that he gives a lot back to his community.
Lovemusicfood, you're hillarious and dead right. Matisyahu is from a reform family. He's basically a bornagain Jew. The whole Hascidic Orthodox outfit is not his culture. It's something he adopted like a seventeen-year-old buying Berkenstocks to wear to his first Phish show. Why did he adopt it? True religious fanaticism? I doubt it? Marketing convenience and chicanery... probably. Anyway.. that issue aside. His music is way better than Creed, man. Show the man a little love... he's just a little confused about who he is.

Chapelchilla starstarstarstarstar Thu 12/14/2006 08:29PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I do not pretend to know anyone elses motivations but I gotta say some of these comments are just rude and ignorant. You don't believe in something? Great, that does not make other peoples belief's less legit. You do not KNOW, they do not KNOW either. Dont want to hear about something? Dont read it. Other folks might like to learn as much as they can.
I am no Matisyahu fanboy but I did see him play an excellent show at the Cat's Cradle. I think he has talent and a little bit of spirituality too. Hell, I even prayed at the show. Not cause he pushed it on me (I do not like to be preached to and I do not even go to Church) but because there was a vibe in the air.
PS-I think Jambase was covering Matisyahu back when JDub records was the label too. You know high powered, big money JDub...that stuff rubbed me the wrong way, peace ya'll

mr2bits Thu 12/14/2006 09:28PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Chapelchilla. My complaint isnt that I don't want to see pieces on Matisyahu. My complaint, which you inadvertently proved when you said "PS-I think Jambase was covering Matisyahu back..." is that Matisyahu has enjoyed more than his fair share of exposure on this site already. There are so many more artists out there. Trumping for some of them would be a much better use of this site (ESPECIALLY those groups that don't already have a major label backing them).

Want to learn more about Matisyahu? Well why don't you check out archives of the CBS Morning Show, The Carson Daly Show, The Late Late Show, Jay Leno, or the following link (apparently he was the XBOX artist of the month for June of this year)
http://www.xbox.com/en-US/live/artist/matisyahu.htm

But please spare me the notion that I am somehow close-minded because I expect this site to give me a little more than recycled fluff-pieces on artists with major label backing.

And just so nobody mistakes this: There is NOTHING wrong with an artist attaining commercial success. More power to the guy. But when you achieve commercial success, people can get info about you from a wide array of mainstream sources. I just expect to hear more that I don't already know from this site than I would, say MTV.com.

My gripe is a legit one, and longtime users of this site are starting to turn elsewhere because of it. Its one thing to dog a guy like Matisyahu on a show review (I HATE it when people come on here and bitch because Jambase had the nerve to review a DMB/Jack Johnson type show). Its a completely different thing to demand that the site show love to the little guys on the circuit, which this site seems to be doing less and less of over time.

You're completely right when you say that Jambase was covering Matisyahu back in the day. But who is the up-and-comer that they're NOT covering NOW because they decided to spend give Matisyahu the same interview he's been giving for the last 2 years? I believe it's a completely fair question.

GRATFULGABE star Thu 12/14/2006 09:30PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

GRATFULGABE

Blah Blah Blah.... Let me know where he is playing and when....So I can see and hear it for myself....Church...Temple...Whatever....I thought this was Jambase....If the guy Jams more power to him.....I love music and freedom....Lets let the guy do his thing. We can embrace it or pass it on. I thought this artilce sucked..........

jerryil Thu 12/14/2006 10:12PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jerryil

chruch, cult, synagoge, mosque, all mean the same thing ie. place of worship..... and I'm the idiot?

All Loving Liberal White Guy Thu 12/14/2006 10:40PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

whether, you like matisyahu or not, this article is going to make for one interesting comment board.

AdCo Thu 12/14/2006 10:41PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

From personal experience, the description of north-east suburban highschool neo-heads was spot on. copious amounts of herb...the good old days. these religious arguments are nonsense, except for lovemusicfoods contention that judaism is not real. thats just plain ignorant. if the comment was intended to insult people, youre just a jackass. and if you really wanted to discuss the "reality" of any religion, youre obviously lacking any understanding of the purpose of religion itself. people utilize religion to help make sense of this crazy and confusing world, and you should realize that everyone makes sense of things in a way that works best for him or her. it may be kinda difficult, but just try to accept the fact that everyones world is his own, and we all just do what we gotta do. try to be understanding. be kind.

Zander75 starstarstarstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 12:12AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Zander75

Reading this article, I knew there were going to heaps of ridiculously mis-informed, unintelligent comments, but WOW...you kids amazed me on this one!

Having met this dude back in the day, at a Bar Mitzvah in Scarsdale, I know one thing - there are dozens if not hundreds of thousands of Matthew MIllers out there...rich, Jewish kids with too much money and a thirst for live jamband music.

He found it. He found G-d too, obviously. The kid is talented, for sure, no doubt, and seems sincere, and I wish him luck (though at this point he probably doesn't need it). But hey, if he convince some FRAT dick to pay attention to the world around him for one minute, all the power too him!

msb696 Fri 12/15/2006 06:04AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

msb696

Two comments:
lovemusicfood: "The reason it's fake is that the religion itself is not real." I agree with this. It's not that the holocaust didn't happen (an absurd connection), or that religion is inherently evil, but the fact that god is a contradiction in and of itself. Anything that worships a contradition is going to be false.

Zander75: That's what his music is - for frat boys. They will pay attention to the true meaning of his songs as much as every white boy thinks they "understand" bob marley's music.

I have a similar background to Matis, but I turned out an atheist. I know and understand the religious community that he has put himself in, and while he may fervently believe what he is doing is the right path, its still just a marketing gimmick to sell records. Jews are not supposed to proselytize, and that is where he diverted from his Carlebach roots. Carlebach and that movement try to preach to people who are already Jewish, not MTV and TRL.

Zarathrusta Fri 12/15/2006 06:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Zarathrusta

I'm on my way out the door for work, so I only had time to read a couple of the shorter comments. So all I'll say for now is that I do respect him for making money with such an obvious gimmick. Except, our community should be able to see right through something like this. So my only complaint is that I'm STILL seeing his fake phoney ass on jamebase and appearing at festivals like langerado why???????
And, to any of his fans reading this.........actually never mind I don't want to reach into the man's pockets, you keep on "believing"

standingtaller starstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 07:32AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

standingtaller

I'm sure there is politics around money, JDub, etc., but such is life, regardless of your beliefs, when fame and fortune set in.

All that matters is the music and this guy is making God OK to sing about, which is hard to do in the growing god-haters out there. His positive vibes can make a Jew, Christina or Muslim smile in knowing there is something greater than us.

Thanks Matisyahou and Happy Holidays to everyone.
GO SEE LIVE MUSIC!

HOPEFULPHAN Fri 12/15/2006 08:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

this dude is a scam. its all advertising. ex phishhead turned rapper? he went to one phish show! thats right one show! i live in minneapolis where he is from and we know some of the same people. his label realized a jewish rapper was a market that hadnt been done and figured he was as good as the next jewish kid. so this whole phishhead story was made up. its true he likes to listen to phish, but one show doesnt make you a phish head.

jasonthehead starstarstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 09:19AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jasonthehead

Man..there are some really stupid, closed-minded, over-generalized comments out here...lovemusicfood, msb696, Henry Chinaski, HOPEFULPHAN (what are you hoping for? Oh yeah, don't remind me...Coventry 2?)

Sure Matisyahu might be a little too popular to get this kind of exposure on JamBase, but with his appearances at the very music fests that this site covers you can't really fault this piece. It's well written and it informed me on a few things about Matisyahu that I didn't know.

As with most musicians/bands/singer-songwriters/performers I like...I don't give a shit about this guy's religion, politics, or background. He's an artist, and what matters is his art, which happens to be a beautiful style of music that connects to a much larger group of fans than most of you realize. "Only for frat boys," are you freaking kidding me!? Even though I doubt the accuracy of the statement that Matisyahu "only went to one Phish show," if it's true it tells me that this guy is pretty smart as well as being pretty talented.

I've always had a love for reggae music and intelligent, harmonic rap and hip-hop....and this guy's music falls right into that musical place in my heart.

msb696 Fri 12/15/2006 10:10AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

msb696

Anyone see the latest setlist? I heard he did a sick jerusalem>hatikva>jerusalem>king>jerusalem.

Summer 07, I'm quitting my job and going on tour!

*yawn*

Luthur Fri 12/15/2006 10:32AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Maybe he can help his buddy,Trey.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/1215062trey1.html

AdCo Fri 12/15/2006 10:59AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

and in response to the "fratboy" claim - my mom and a bunch of fogies from her synagogue went to see matis at the tla last night. she said there were people of all ages there. the bottom line is, the guy has a smooth, pure voice and his blend of music appeals to people. the whole "religion as a marketing gimmick" is just silly. maybe his management saw it as a way to help promote him, and why shouldnt they? nobody's saying hes making such a monster impact on music or culture, but hes doin his thing and he sounds good to alot of poeple. just because his drummer doesnt wear a dress and suck a vaccum doesnt mean we have to generalize his fanbase or insult how he does things. so many haters on this website! lets get some interesting, positive threads goin.

phishermen32 starstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 11:47AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

***between Matisyahu and many others who grew up Jewish in upper-middle class, suburban areas with the world at our fingertips and a bong in our hand****

This is both untrue and inappropriate

Smittea star Fri 12/15/2006 12:27PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Smittea

Listen to his album. Both unimpressed by the music and the man behind it. Next!

All Loving Liberal White Guy Fri 12/15/2006 12:39PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

hey HOPEFULPHAN,

Minneapolis? I thought this dude was from West Chester, PA

matttroche Fri 12/15/2006 01:06PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

matttroche

did anyone hear about trey getting busted this morning w/ a bunch of happy pills drunk off his ass driving a car? the smoking gun has his mug shot. it is hilarious.

AdCo Fri 12/15/2006 01:11PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

apparently he passed the breath test, so he wasnt drunk of his ass, just feelin good after smokin some hash and takin some percs and xannys. who can blame him, if i caused phish to break up, id probably want to be heavily medicated too.

MiWi La Lupa starstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 01:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

MiWi La Lupa

Luthur, that's crazy!
all this should make one think twice about dreaming to become a successful, popular artist for whatever reason. Funny to read about your tastes and opinions. Not a bad article though. Given a shout out to Adam Deitch too? Cool.
G-d bless America, my h-me sweet h-me. Better yet, G-d bless the undergr-und!
Peace and love, brothers and sisters. Peace and love!

mr2bits Fri 12/15/2006 01:25PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Jambase has reported it but is keeping discussion on hte topic closed. Half of me applauds them for respecting his privacy. The other half thinks that there is no point censoring a topic that people are going to talk about regardless.

Either way, he's already out of jail, and I wish him luck in the future. And remember folks. Always designate a driver.

lovemusicfood star Fri 12/15/2006 02:26PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

"my mom and a bunch of fogies from her synagogue went to see matis at the tla last night... the whole "religion as a marketing gimmick" is just silly." ---
You've got to be kidding you just disproved your damn point. The only reason your mom and friends were there is because he is "Jewish". Just like when I saw him in Ithaca and a huge portion of people there were from the local college Jewish organizations. Blah

All Loving Liberal White Guy Fri 12/15/2006 02:48PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

trey's real name is ernest?!!!

ĂȘtre Fri 12/15/2006 02:55PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

ĂȘtre

Since when has becoming a Lubavitcher become a marketing gimmick? I doubt that the Matisyahu embracing Hasidic community of Crown Heights shares some of the beliefs posted here. Making teshuva and entering the Orthodox community requires great effort and study, something that is much more time consuming than a quick gimmick to sell music.

Shalom!

HOPEFULPHAN star Fri 12/15/2006 03:08PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

actually trey's 1st name is ernesto. matisyahu said in a relix interview that he did more than just smoke at his one phish show. is that allowed in his strict religion??? my guess is no, further proof its all marketing.....

mr2bits star Fri 12/15/2006 03:27PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

You guys really need to lay off these religion-based objections to the guy. The beauty of a personal belief is that, under no circumstances can it be proven a fraud (or genuine). The fact that "Is he for real or not" is the focal point of the article is the exact reason I consider this article nothing more than a fluff-piece. I'm sure the execs at Sony LOVE IT when people argue back and forth about the convictions of one of their client's hearts.

Luthur Fri 12/15/2006 09:04PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

So much to go through...

first off... I'm not the biggest Phish fan... I had no idea his first name was Ernest. A whole new spin on everything. For no reason at all. Was it common knowledge his name was Ernest? He drove on a suspended license. That happens usually because one got busted before.

As far as no comments on the Trey Bust link... I'm sort of with Mr.2Bits. I can't decide. I think we all know how that thread would go (much friction) but maybe we shouldn't go there. Kind of like a bad accident. No one wants to see it yet everybody would be there.

And now... hell.. Mr.2Bits again! I really see what you are saying with your 3:27 post. I don't believe a reason to hate or love a human being should be based on religion. I have no idea whether or not Matishyahoooo spouts is what he believes in. I do know he has a 1/2 ass reggae bar band backing him.

totalot starstarstar Fri 12/15/2006 09:31PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

whatever...phish kid takes a hit and realizes that he can get a bunch of people to see him if he becomes a jewish and raps....are all good white rapper jewish? Beasties, 3rd Base etc. If you are sucker enough to fall into this gimmick then....have fun while your doing it.

Matthew Jaworski star Sat 12/16/2006 08:38AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Matthew Jaworski

Preface: I somewhat like Matis. Downloaded and enjoyed a few songs from Stubbs and Youth, but haven't had the desire to revisit them.

What I'm confused about is why a lot of people think he's being "gimmicky" or that it's just a "marketing ploy." What marketing/music/advertising company would have ever had the foresight to think that an Orthodox Jew doing reggae would be profitable, marketable, or break-through? Are these naysayers mostly Jewish, who know the particulars of his form of Judaism, and feel he's breaking certain rules?

If he was just trying to make a buck, I can think of hundreds of easier, less-risky and more profitable "scams" that he could be trying to pull off.

Mr2bits - I enjoyed reading your posts. I was not expecting to read the same Matis bio article that I've read numerous times before.

krsmall Sat 12/16/2006 11:25AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

matisyahu rocks or stfu
why does everyone call him a gimmick? jewish reggae wasnt played on the radio before him.

Ned8 starstar Sat 12/16/2006 02:13PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I agree with some; get on the cut fella's. I have seen at least four unknowns on Myspace that knocked my socks off

Ned8 starstar Sat 12/16/2006 02:14PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I think it funny that there are actually people out there that make the pre-tense that because there is a stated contradiction about the question of G-D that it is not valid. In Judaism, G-D is represented as everything but it is still a question; one that is past our comprehension. We are given this life to perform mitzvah (Blessings) and suduka (Good acts to others) the problem the reader seems to have is that he cannot base it in judgmental Christian reign of absolutes. This is what makes me proud of being Jewish. I know the article is a step away from what I have enjoyed about Jambase but I’m thankful that the site is expounding and touching on other music other than just Jambands. I do like the fact that we get individuals who express thus causing a chain reaction where music is culture and identity and opinion snap out. (You know the frat boys on Borat are suing over their beliefs; that they don’t want to stand by them) The only problem with the internet is that those with opinion who have an impact when they state their opinion can do it hidden away from the community whereby we cannot look into the eyes of someone who believes ignorant thoughts and get into dialog so we can cure Anti-Semites and Bigots of limiting thoughts. I’m not a big fan of the artist but if it touches someone it’s a Mitzvah
In a way you are right
 Judaism is not a religious; it is a way to be thankful for life and do well in this world; a spiritual and physical form of doing in this life rather than assuming the next
 IN OTHERWORDS BE HERE NOW

Darkstar16 star Sat 12/16/2006 04:18PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

more matisyahu fluffing? Oh joy...

Jonesah starstarstarstar Sun 12/17/2006 11:05AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I don't quite understand why people can't appreciate music for what it is, regardless of whether or not it is sincere. It either moves you or it doesn't. If it doesn't, what is the point in criticizing the musician?

msb696 Mon 12/18/2006 07:45AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

msb696

Ned8: Not to get in a flame-war on Jambase about Judaism, but you are wrong about Judaism in general, and what a "mitzvah" is in particular. A Mitzvah is most often an act of kindness, and tzedakha is charity. Judaism is certainly a religion, and I am afraid that whoever taught you about it had no idea what they were talking about.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitzvah

ujawoma: He is not really breaking any laws, but not acting in accordance with the teachings of his leaders. I don't think the record companies went searching for him, rather he was caught in the middle between his secular music life, and his religious life. By making music about God, he was able to combine them both. The problem that I have, is when he starts getting traction on MTV, and going to festivals, he is longer in it purely to glorify god, but to make a few bucks.

Guanoskimer star Mon 12/18/2006 10:58AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I've seen Matisyahu something like 4 times, and I usually can groove off his performances, but not because of him. I really just dig the musicians who back him up. Most Matis songs sound incredibly similar, his lyrics are pretty corny, and there's just nothing for any person with musical knowledge to thrive off of in the music of Matisyahu. I'm sad to see someone on Jambase covering the ass off a sellout artist, rather than support an artist who could use some publicity. No matter how much we'd all like to argue about whether or not Matis is a gimmick, when it comes down to it, his music is uninspired, repetitive, and lacking talent. Supposedly Matis decided to become orthodox after tripping on acid at a phish show and seeing the face of god, so when it comes down to it, the man is just a stoner wearing a funny hat. All this man is spreading is the perpetuation of the view of people who follow bands around as lacking motivation and direction in life. He keeps saying that he had to figure out his life, but what's wrong with following a band around. The guy's a joke, and he just is another head to turn around and feed back into the capitalist ideals of today's American society.

iamzero starstarstar Mon 12/18/2006 11:23AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

iamzero

I respect Matisyahu for what he represents but when I saw him I really didn't get into the music too much. I'm not sure if it was just the lousy acoustics at the venue though...

I think he is a legit follower of orthodox judaism. Who are we to question his motives?

It's nice to see someone stepping up to the plate as a figurehead for the jewish youth of america.

yes i'm jewish haha...although not practicing.

hjgarcia Mon 12/18/2006 01:52PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

hjgarcia

i think he's great
but really

his band is TIGHT!
all new school jazz guys, apparently...and they play like it
i think what he's doing is something very good and don't question his motives at all
he's got good flow...the lyrics are whatever
but the band is the show, i think

jon932 star Mon 12/18/2006 02:05PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

agree with the guy who said this is a horribly written article. What is ironic about celebrating at an Italian restaurant? Every paragraph seems like a combination of incomplete thoughts or ideas from other paragraphs. If this writer actually interviewed Matis, the only indication we'd have is from the "i'm giving props to myself for knowing my shit Sizzla" reference. I thought the article was supposed to be about his authenticity or lack thereof? I'm more confused after reading the article than before. I hope Matis liked you, since that appears to be your goal in writing. I have no opinion on Matis. I wanted to learn more about him and read something interesting at lunch. I'll print out the boxscores from last nights shows next time. Clean it up Jambase!!

daillest star Mon 12/18/2006 03:07PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I a big Matisyahu fan, both of his lyrics, and of the band, and know his motives are sincere. The problem with this article, is that it's the exact same one that has been written about Matisyahu two-dozen times, and most likely at leats once before on Jambase. Great artist, very weak article

daillest star Mon 12/18/2006 03:07PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I'm a big Matisyahu fan, both of his lyrics, and of the band, and know his motives are sincere. The problem with this article, is that it's the exact same one that has been written about Matisyahu two-dozen times, and most likely at leats once before on Jambase. Great artist, very weak article

Mdpickles star Mon 12/18/2006 03:16PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

What?? This finook is getting praise for being the first Jewish rapper/beat boxer/reggae artist from some of you? He dropped out of high school for one Phish show?? Im confused, as is Jambase, on this piece. Just don't understand any relevance to what this article is trying to piece together. And really, there is no irony in him having his baz mitzvah in an Italian rest..unless the tip was lousy as shit, then it would make sense.
GO SEE REAL LIVE MUSIC

Mdpickles Mon 12/18/2006 03:20PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Sooo. Thier won't be a Matisyahu X-Mas/Hannukah album titled, "How To Kill One Of Your Own."?? Darn

Ned8 star Mon 12/18/2006 03:58PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

msb696
I never stated it was not a religion I stated that there is a beautiful contradiction in it would confuse a western Christian as to its motives as such. Mitzvah (Hebrew: מצווה, IPA: [ˈmɪtsvə], "commandment"; plural, mitzvot; from צוה, tzavah, "command") is a word used in Judaism to refer to (a) the commandments, of which there are 613, given in the Torah (the first five books of the Hebrew Bible) or (b) any Jewish law at all. fulfillment of a mitzvah as defined above.
I’m not saying your wrong but I’m sure of this.
Now; I do know one thing.... You are a Zionist and therefore I'm quite sure that you don't understand the difference between being Jewish and the contradiction ofbeing a Zionist Jew rather than one who respect other people.
Next time do you research rather than trying to speak like you are superior, understand this ; Like most Hebrew it denotes a few meanings the revelence but then of course you knew that... Blow hard

Ned8 star Mon 12/18/2006 04:21PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Forgot to mention tzedakha is not Cherity... There is no direct translation of the word
The closest thing to it is Hagel
Try reading some of his work and then you can really understand the philosophical depth of Judaism
It is a self affirming act which is a good deed yes but not charity denotes pity. I hope you recognize the difference. I think you have mixed Judaic-Christian belief into something acceptable to Zionism. Oh by the way
 Did you enjoy Hanukkah so you felt like you had something to hold up while all your non-Jewish friends had Christmas?
For those of you who don’t know
Hanukkah is an insignificant holiday in Judaism that is not found in the torah 

OK; I’m done

Kindskatz Tue 12/19/2006 08:27AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Kindskatz


The guy always sounds off key.....there's really nothing special about him.....he's a novelty act that already, clearly, wearing off......he was huge last summer, now who gives a shit about him?

MixedBagProductions starstarstarstarstar Tue 12/19/2006 10:37AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

MixedBagProductions

Matisyaboooooooooo!!!!! I loved this guy at first, then I found out he was totally full of sh*t. SELLOUT!

EVILFUNK starstarstarstarstar Tue 12/19/2006 12:44PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

EVILFUNK

yeah, anybody who wants to hear real beat box mastery should run down SF beat box genious Tim Barsky!

matttroche Tue 12/19/2006 02:11PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

matttroche

ok seriously enough maits bashing. dude puts out some wicked music! all that stuff about him being a sellout or a phoney is just the typical gerneralization that people in the community start saying the second an artist gets a little mainstream attention. just listen to the music, forget all the hype.

Geostar starstarstar Tue 12/19/2006 03:06PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Not a sellout? I don't know, everytime I hear that jerusalem song and that "aint nobody gonna break my stride" part, I cringe.

I've seen him twice now and have no desire to see him again. I'll agree that he is personable and has some good songs, but I just don't like the direction he is going with his music.

jerryil star Tue 12/19/2006 05:00PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jerryil

If you want to hear someone sing really badly out of tune, goto the archive and listen to something by this jerk. His music all sounds the same, the words would make Bob Marley sick, and oh yeah........... stay in tune you joke of an artist. I've heard better regae bands for $2 at a bar.

AdCo Tue 12/19/2006 05:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

AdCo

Lovemusicfood and Hopefulphan...you guys are douches. furthermore, everyone's arguing about the marketing behind matis. like it or not, every band or musician needs to market itself or himself, promotion is a necessary part of the music business. gimmicks and ploys bring heads to shows, then they can decide if they like the music or not, and if theyll continue to see the act or bitch about it on message boards. its life, get over it.

spaceface7 star Wed 12/20/2006 05:27AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

This article was almost as bad as "youth". I can't wait to forget this guys name

Zarathrusta Wed 12/20/2006 05:52AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Zarathrusta

I have a few friends who like this guy and what they all have in common is the fact that their music collection contains (other than a Bob Marley compilation) very little if any Underground Hip Hop or Reggae. No true Hip Hop Head I know likes this guy at all. So if you are a fan of his, ask yourself if maybe it's because it's your first time being exposed to Hip Hop that is not about diamonds, prostitutes and guns. Try some real Underground artists like Mr. Lif or Imortal Technique and get some perspective.

jimcard Wed 12/20/2006 08:40AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Is there any truth to the rumors that Matisyahu will not share a stage with females? Thought I heard this not long ago.

I know asking a question regarding rumors on a discussion board is like asking a prison full of inmates whether they are guilty or innocent, but I am asking anyways.

rjd999 Wed 12/20/2006 09:20AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I dont necessarily believe that Matisyahu himself is a gimmick, but I do believe the reason he is selling so many records is based on the gimmick. He gives a nation of suburban white kids something else to listen to other than Bob or Bone Thugs to listen to while they are smoking up. Reggae music is near and dear to me, and I love so much of it. And while Matisyahu isnt really bad, he does have a cool cadance and rhythm to his vocals, his voice is awful whenever he actually tries to do anything with melody, and his lyrics are self righteous, preachy, and hypocritcal at times. I admit, I was into it at first, but just because it was a breath of fresh air and something a little different. Then, after taking a step back, and actually listening to the music with an unbiased approach, I kinda realized that it was of sub-par quality, espescially when it comes to reggae music. Give me Lutan Fyah or Anthony B or Sizzla any day over Matisyahu. I think noone here on jambase is into judging people for their beliefs and culture, and I do think thats why Matisyahu took off, just because everyone was so enthralled in the idea that he was (WOW!) Jewish... However, his backing band, Roots Tonic, is the shit... check out the album that they did with Bill Laswell... dub massive shit, bangin

shooda487 Wed 12/20/2006 09:43AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

To respond to the rumors : I wouldnt be surprised if he didnt share the stage with any females because it is against the Torah for a man to sing with or listen to a female singing live. Matis is a religeous man and i dont think he would violate the torah for a show.

Smittea starstarstar Wed 12/20/2006 11:27AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Smittea

Real name: Matthew Paul Miller

Hebrew Name: Feivish Hershel

Stage Name: Matisyahu

I would call that a gimmick. AND the music isn't very good. It is extremely redundant and he sings too much. You can't actually hear the musicians because he is always gabbing away. One thing is for sure, his music is far better than any crap I could make.

jas121 Wed 12/20/2006 01:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I saw Matisyahu on Saturday night and the intolerant crowd booed Mr. Lif off the stage. I feel really bad about this - especially after the bus crash and that this was his only show after the rest of his tour was canceled. Matisyahu did nothing to tell his fans that booing was the wrong thing to do. He mentioned nothing to his fans that (1) booing a performer is inappropriate; (2) when you are crowd of Jews booing a black performer you appear racist; and (3)it's not particularly Jewish to be openly intolerant of that which is different. I'm pretty disillusioned.

MixedBagProductions Wed 12/20/2006 02:26PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

MixedBagProductions

The rumor is 100% true. He will NOT perform on stage with a woman.

mr2bits Wed 12/20/2006 09:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jas121

Can you give us a little more context to how any why the booing occurred. Was it as soon as he was announced? Something he said? I'm guessing it may have been for his stance on U.S. involvement in the Middle East. Am I missing something here?

All Loving Liberal White Guy Wed 12/20/2006 10:05PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

did anybody see that episode of curb your enthusiam where that orthodox jewish woman had to jump off that ski lift becasue she couldn't be alone with larry david after sundown?

nfenne star Thu 12/21/2006 08:13AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

nfenne

ADCO said: "apparently he passed the breath test, so he wasnt drunk of his ass, just feelin good after smokin some hash and takin some percs and xannys. who can blame him"

I have no problem with people taking drugs but lets face the truth: NO ONE SHOULD BE DRIVING WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF XANNAX. It's a bad idea.

Otherwise.. play ball!

jas121 Thu 12/21/2006 08:34AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I wasn't there from the beginning of his set, but I remember that the booing really peaked when Mr. Lif was performing Brothaz and would say "Brothers is taught to bust shots." Of course, this comes in the context of a song with lines like "I shitted on Bush" and "See how costless holocaust is?" Come to think of it, perhaps this was not the best pairing on the concert organizer's part.

festijam12 Thu 12/21/2006 10:17AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

yeah Condi Style...i saw that episode, ridiculously hilarious...if you want to see/watch a true jewish comedic act, watch curb your enthusiasm, absolutely hysterical

All Loving Liberal White Guy Thu 12/21/2006 02:11PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

remember that episode of seinfeld where jerry got upset because his dentist, dr tim whatley converted to judiasm for the jokes and jerry gott offended as a comedian and not as a person as the jewish faith. what about that time when kramer had to cook all that food for the jewish singles mixer and then frank costanza got shell shock from his days in korea from having served some rotten beef. what about when larry david renewed his wedding vowels with his wife and accidently stomped and smashed the rabbi's fingers under the glass when he scremed "mazeltov"! funny shit.

mulenutz starstar Fri 12/22/2006 09:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

There was a Curb Your Enthusiasm were Larry had to have sex with a woman through a cut-out hole in a bed-sheet. Her religion prohibited their bodies from touching.

Would Matisyahu allow a woman on stage if she was covered with a bed-sheet singing through a cut-out hole? Or maybe they would both have to be covered with a bed-sheet? I'm not sure. I'm confused from all the Xanax and painkillers.

All Loving Liberal White Guy Mon 12/25/2006 01:18PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

remember that curb your enthusiam where larry david invited that registered sex offender over to the cedar dinner.

Ned8 star Tue 12/26/2006 02:22PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I'm absolutely embarrassed that the crowd booed and as well astonished that MATISYAHU did not speak out. It goes to show; Hello!!!!! This guy saw the face of G-D at a Phish show while on drugs and then decides to become Orthodox.... Wait a second. G-d in Judaism has no face; has no form; it is all energy. What is going on here? Well, if people will just remember that like most Christians don't take responsibility for David Duke it means we do not have to take responsibility for MATISYAHU
No, Kramer is not Jewish and yes, I never saw a black person on Seinfeld and I hate the show anyway though Curb your enthusiasm is awesome
Oh; I would not have even looked at this board again but I had to see if my response before was answered... I talked to my rabbi to check my facts. My rabbi said for a self hating Jew you are right on point LOL (Yes ,he supports Zionism)

shooda487 starstarstar Wed 12/27/2006 10:51AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Lovemusicfood, what are talking about when you said "The reason it's fake is that the religion itself is not real" that is incredibly offensive and ignorant. Judaism is the original monotheistic religion, and the jewish people are the longest lasting, religion abiding nation in world history. the other religions "of the book" (christianity and islam), all share common morals with the precedents set by Judaism thousands of years ago. as for the booing , anyone remember the crown heights race riots of 91' ? unfortunately there could be some fans who may still have issues with members of the black community.

All Loving Liberal White Guy Wed 12/27/2006 04:03PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

never saw a black person on seidfeld?!! ned8, what are you smoking? what about joe, the dude whose place george went to watch breakfast at tiffany's? or mr. morgan, carl the exterminator, that pizza delivery dude who was allergic to kramers mohair sweater when they thought that their accountant was on blow, the black girl that kramer dated when he fell asleep in the tanning booth for too long and her father who said "you said you was bringin a white boy home. all i see is a damn fool!!" or the dude who runs monks diner who threatened to make george his own personal hand puppet, or that dentist who jerry needed to see when he crashed tim whatleys party, or jean paul the trinidadian runner who slept in too late, or one of the producers whose 'scarsdale suprise' tony award that kramer took, or that lady who ran the volunteer program for the elderly, or that nurse from senegal who putt baby oil on georges bald head so that he could rub it on her body, or the jamacian woman named coco that george hired as VP for kruger industrial smoothing so that he could get his t-bone nickname back, or walter from j petermans office, or stanley ipswich the accountant, or that dude who refused to drive elaine around the parking garage. i could go on and on.

festijam12 Thu 12/28/2006 11:50AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I must say im impressed by Condis knowledge of Seinfeld and Curb...which kind of helped me with this idea...on the next season of curb, Larry David should go to a Matisyahu show, somehow meet him backstage and have a conversation that reflects this postboard...could be hilarious, hopefully Larry David checks Jambase frequently

custiechump Thu 12/28/2006 12:37PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

custiechump

X box! they wouldnt sponsor anyone who was not good, right...theese are the people who make it possable to PRETEND you are playing guitaur! they know all about music! this guy must be good too. right? .....right?

All Loving Liberal White Guy Thu 12/28/2006 02:54PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

remember that time on seinfeld when the moyle circumsized jerrys finger?

"i coulda been a kosher butcher like my brother. the pay is good and there's a union". - Shakey the Moyle

All Loving Liberal White Guy Thu 12/28/2006 03:07PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

oh yeah, i almost forgot. did anybody see that one burb your enthusiam where larry david stole the fork from the resturanut and when he went to court he saw that the judge had a jewish last name and tried to greet him by saying shalom and pissing him off even more and then when the judge asked him what a fitting punishment would be, larry suggested that he help out at temple on saturday. the judge was all like: "isn't temple suppposed to be a joy for you sir"? where larry responded "temple can be quite grueling sir."

lovemusicfood star Sat 12/30/2006 09:27AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Judaism is not the original monotheism. From what I have learned the Jewish ideas started from a Pharoah named Akenatan. He probably didn't originate it either. Plus Judaism is not one thing. Just like Christianity or any religion it is not a set thing so there have been and still are many version throughout history. Either they are all real or none of them are real.

Ned8 star Sat 12/30/2006 02:00PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

lovemusicfood
You may want to check your facts on that one. I beleive Jewish Mystic writings pre-date the Pharoh's

All Loving Liberal White Guy Sat 12/30/2006 06:49PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

All Loving Liberal White Guy

hey ned8. you obviously forgot the lawyer jackie chiles.

"This is lewd, lascivious, salacious, outrageous! Of course a bra's not going to fit on over a leotard. A bra's got to fit right up against a person's skin...like a glove!

hellyeah Wed 1/3/2007 11:56PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

actually if i am not mistaken zoroastrianism is an essentially monotheistic religion that predates either akhenaton or judaism. but are we really arguing here about who's imaginary friend has been collectively hallucinated for a longer period of time or about how bad matisyahu sucks, purely musically speaking, all theological delusions aside.

ashellen Thu 1/4/2007 07:18AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

ashellen

i just heard that Matisyahu and Snow are going to be co-headling a spring world tour. i cant wait to hear "Informer" with a backing band.

elaufer Mon 1/8/2007 11:50PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Matisyahu a gimmick? As far as I can tell, he is one of the few musicians ever to be publicly jewish. Bob Dylan's real name is Robert Zimmerman. Had the balls to tell the powers that be, that they were full of shit, but didn't have the balls to use his real, obviously jewish name. Why is it allright for Jamaican Rastas like Marley to constantly preach religion, but not Matisyahu?

Since when do people on Jambase not like Gimmicks? Please . . phish did a cappella versions of freebird and did vacuum solos. If those aren't gimmicks I don't know what is.

And as long as we're talking about phish, I have a message to all the trey bashers out there: You are the biggest bunch of unappreciative whiners I have ever heard. This man gave you his heart and soul on stage for nearly two decades. He undoubtedly did more than you to create your scene (much,much,much,much . . .much more than you did). And he now has some serious chemical problems (as many musicians do) from a lifetime on the road that he has to deal with, without the benefit of the love from you, that would almost certainly help him.

"All things must pass." Be it phish, or life. You can either deal with that passing positively or negatively. The choice is yours.

karacter0 star Tue 1/9/2007 12:12PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

karacter0

i was going to comment on how this faker is not jamaican and then compare him to Snow, but someone beat me to it.

just imagine if Phish faked a chinese accent their whole carrer. people who listen to non-jamaican reggae are pawns.

Matisyahu should tour with Brittany Spears!

lovemusicfood star Tue 1/9/2007 03:19PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

HellYeah that was funny!

nonoodlejam star Sun 1/21/2007 10:41PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

This writer is a hack. I haven't agree with anything I've read by him.

nfenne Fri 1/26/2007 11:42AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

nfenne

elaufer: How can you use criticize Bob Dylan for changing his name? Do you think Matisyahu is this guy's name?

Musicians and actors change their name all the time regardless of heritage.

breadloaf Thu 2/1/2007 08:51AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Regardless of one's personal taste and feelings about Matis, the article was not exactly a pillar of objective journalism. I don't think the word "fawning" would be inappropriate to describe the writing here.

keegzo Mon 2/5/2007 07:04AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

keegzo

jewish reggae at its best the mans got some talent
read half an article and not terrble

jaeki16 starstarstarstar Mon 2/19/2007 08:14PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Matisyahu is no gimmick. His sound derives from dancehall, reggae, hip-hop, and rock and he skillfully weaves them together. Any fan of any of those types of music should be able to recognize the multiple genres found in his music and acknowledge and --at the very least-- respect what he does. I plan to attend every show that I can.