Green Day | 04.07.09 | San Francisco

  • View Comments
  • Send to a Friend

By: Troy Blanchard

Green Day :: 04.07.09 :: The Independent :: San Francisco, CA

Green Day
Green Day's rise from East Bay punk club favorites to stadium-filling superstars always seemed to present a challenge to the band. For a group of homebodies that thrived on the intimacy and sense of community of their Gilman Street era, the band has worked hard to retain that close and interdependent relationship with their audience, as well as the sense of spontaneity and controlled chaos that fuels any great rock show – something that's suffered in the age of cell phone cameras and YouTube clips. For years the band at each show has brought on stage three lucky audience members to take over each instrument and vamp on a cover of Operation Ivy's "Knowledge," and Billie Joe Armstrong has always enjoyed giving the front row fans a Super Soaker shower. No matter how large the venue, no Green Day show passes without such close, playful interaction with the fans.

Nevertheless, the band sacrificed some of its punk randomness and free flow with the massive American Idiot Tour, complete with pyrotechnics, confetti showers and giant LCD screens. I saw three American Idiot Tour shows and for the most part they were top-notch but identical with only a few surprises here and there. After all that, how can you stay... punk? Well, announcing and playing a small venue show on the same day is a hell of a way to do it. The suddenness of the announcement ('live without warning') and the ensuing phone calls, texts, emails and general internet chatter amongst local fans lit a fuse on what would ignite a powder-keg three hour show in the heart of San Francisco.

Green Day staged a surprise attack on The Bay for both themselves and the fans. Growing tall from grass roots, Green Day may be one of the biggest bands on the planet, but they are doing it their way - and that means keeping it close to the source, which in this case means playing a tiny club in their backyard. Taking the stage just after 10 p.m., the band opened with the battle tested "Welcome to Paradise" before launching into a song-by-song rendition of the upcoming album 21st Century Breakdown (arriving May 15 and produced by Butch Vig). "We have a new album coming out, and we're gonna play just about all the songs from it tonight," announced Billie Joe. The band tore into the new album, playing with a definite sense of confidence and pride in their new material.

21st Century Breakdown does not depart from the sound or lyrics of American Idiot. It is very much the exciting next chapter in the continuing tale of punks, suburbia, religion and, of course, the roller coaster of growing up. Armstrong, taking his queues from Pete Townshend, offers a three-part structure to the 21st Century Breakdown story: "Heroes and Cons," "Charlatans and Saints," and "Horseshoes and Handgrenades" (more on this here). There is not much let up in the take-to-the-streets politics of the lyrics, and we again have punk presented in epic nine-minute collages. First single "Know Your Enemy" is a fist punching, one riff, ready-made anthem that captures the sense of confusion and bleakness of the day with its ambiguous question, "Do you know your enemy?"

"Viva la Gloria" opens with piano and Armstrong on vocals, a new sonic texture for the band, and finds the group in a melodic instrumental interlude with dueling guitar solo parts. "Christian's Inferno" is pure Ramones, while "Desperate" is the musical sibling to American Idiot's "Letterbomb." A standout was the start of the opus' third act, "Horseshoes and Handgrenades," a shorter, stripped down version of the "Jesus of Suburbia" punk epic. Other material echoed their earlier work like super hit "Blvd. of Broken Dreams" and the gypsy-rocker "Misery" off 2000's Warning.

After the world premiere of their new work, the band took a quick break and returned to the stage for what would be a revival hour for top hits and old school favorites. The band tore into "American Idiot" and "Jesus of Suburbia" with the same intensity of four years previous. The band then wove through their massive catalogue, all the way back to "Going To Pasalacqua" from 1991's 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours onto 1992's Kerplunk with "Christie Road" and "Who Wrote Holden Caulfield?," as well as the seminal Dookie for "Longview," "She" and "F.O.D.," a song not played live for many, many years. The band also brought out the sentimental "Macy's Day Parade" and party-rocker "King for a Day/Shout." The band, with seemingly unlimited energy, capped off the night with polka-punk closer "Minority."

Green Day
The band that always sells out stadiums around the world came into a venue that held no more than 500 people. I was also lucky enough to have seen the group perform as the Foxboro Hottubs last May in the even smaller Stork Club in Oakland (a show also announced with similar sudden notice on an unsuspecting hometown fan base), and it's clear the band still seeks that small venue energy, excitement and spontaneous play-anywhere, anytime, any day spirit (seek out YouTube videos of the teenaged band playing at their Pinole Valley High School during recess for some vintage evidence). Unlike large venue Green Day shows, there were no children or emo-teens in attendance at this 21-and-over gig, which offered older fans a chance to not feel, well, old, at a Green Day show. For a band that can get Giants Stadium on its feet from its opening number until the house lights come up, The Independent served as a very, very loud punk club, complete with mosh-pit and crowd surfing, with the band free from reliance on timed pyrotechnics and lighting cues - several second set songs were spontaneous audience requests. To stay punk, sometimes it's good to play without any real rules.

Green Day, now numbering up to six musicians on stage, is a band that has only grown in skill, showmanship and raw power over their career. Watching one of the biggest acts in music play a show that would rival Springsteen in intensity, breadth and duration to a few hundred very lucky hometown fans was a true treat, particularly for a fan that first saw the band play Oakland in 1995 at the old Henry J. Kaiser arena. Green Day, in their rise to the top of the music world, has not gotten too big for a guerilla-style show with their core fans, and has found the best way to stay grounded is to still play anytime, anywhere, and give it everything you've got.

04.07.09 :: The Independent :: San Francisco, CA

Set I:

Welcome to Paradise

Act I: Heroes and Cons
21st Century Breakdown
Know Your Enemy
Viva la Gloria
Before the Lobotomy
Christian's Inferno
Last Night on Earth

Act II: Charlatans and Saints
East Jesus Nowhere
Peacemaker
Last of the American Girls
Murder City

Act III: Horseshoes and Handgrenades
Restless Heart Syndrome
Horseshoes and Handgrenades
Drama Queen
Static Age
21 Guns
American Eulogy
See the Light

Set II:

American Idiot
Jesus of Suburbia
She
Christie Road
J.A.R.
F.O.D.
Longview
Who Wrote Holden Caulfield
Brainstew [started it, but Billie Joe said "forget it"]
Going to Pasalacqua
Macy's Day Parade
King for a Day/Shout
Minority

JamBase | Yay Area
Go See Live Music!

http://www.greenday.com/

[Published on: 4/9/09]


 

Comments

RaQ&RoLL Thu 4/9/2009 12:13PM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
ClaysTribe star Thu 4/9/2009 12:21PM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
BRabbit Thu 4/9/2009 12:23PM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
Mr_McDankenstein Thu 4/9/2009 12:26PM
+4 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Mr_McDankenstein

You know I've been saying to myself recently...man I hope jambase posts a show review about green day someday. it's really intriguing theyre such great musicians i just can;t wrap my head around it

RichardHaley Thu 4/9/2009 12:28PM
+11 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Man, you people are funny! One of the biggest bands on the planet plays a tiny show and JamBase reviews it 2 days later. What in the fuck is wrong w/ that? I don't really like Green Day, but they are a huge band - i think it's cool it's covered. There's plenty of bands covered on JamBase i don't personally like, but that does not mean it should not be reviewed. Get over yourselves.

Tan starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:29PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Tan

This show was BONKERS! So good!

ClaysTribe Thu 4/9/2009 12:30PM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
JammyJammerson Thu 4/9/2009 12:31PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Seriously Dick, one of the biggest bands on the planet? Is it 1996?

RichardHaley Thu 4/9/2009 12:34PM
+7 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I'm pretty sure when you sell out stadiums around the world and sell millions of albums, you are huge. They generally play to stadiums, they played a 500 person venue - that is cool, and that is good reporting - regardless of taste. And Tribe - is that really the best you can do "Shut it." How about some disucssion, i like talking about music - instead of name calling and shit talkin like 8 yr olds, how about some thoughts on why covering this show was so horrible? annnyyywaayyy....

Slipster starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:37PM
+11 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

great writing. I'm not their core audience - I hadn't listened to them in 10 years. I was a bit ambiguous about scoring tickets at the independent, but at only 20 bucks it was a no brainer. Fantastic show - and why wouldn't jambase cover this?

shanky95 starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:38PM
+12 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

You guys are all fucking mindless. What's wrong with Green Day? None of you owned Dookie? Liars. Recently, they've fallen off a bit and gotten a bit too mainstream and "stadium" for me, but a mainstream band that's actually trying to say something through their music besides Buy, buy, buy and Me, me, me? I'm down for that. I'm also down for the unbelievable, genius, and heart-wrenching lyrics that are "American Idiot". And go ahead and give me thumbs down!! Sometimes music isn't all that's in music. Music can speak too, it can express frustration and beauty if you know how to weave it. "Jam" music is where it's at and it is my first love, but don't miss out on other people's genius just because you're blindly in love with Trey, Dave, Jake, Marc, (most of phish's lyrics, while compelling and thought - provoking, don't lend much importance to today's state of affairs.) That second set looks awesome too. Green Day in a small venue, doing a complete run-through of their new album and then a second set of old favorites? Shut yer mouths! Everyone above is young and fucking dumb.

hrklempner starstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:41PM
+8 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Whoa! You people are TRIPPING. I was at this show and it was retardo montabon good. Dookie was the first album i ever bought, and just because green day isnt the "really exclusive and new upcoming stuff" doesnt mean that they are not a killer band, who is incredibly talented and fan driven. Besides, are you really going to hate on a throw back to 5th grade? Light up people.

shanky95 Thu 4/9/2009 12:44PM
+3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Sorry, lots of people posted as I did, and no not everyone above is fucking dumb... my apologies. And, yes, Green Day IS "one of the" biggest bands on the planet. They could sell-out more stadiums than phish. OH shit!, I said it!!!

jack_straw starstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:46PM
+4 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I have no problem admitting that Green Day played one of the most memorable encores I've ever seen! Back in 2001, they played at Deer Creek on Ozzfest (I think) and after a rowdy set they beat the shit out of their equipment, bashing everything into pieces and throwing it all in in a heaping pile. Then they come back out and light the pile on fire, and Billy Joe does "Time of Your Life" on an acoustic. Incredible...

kfk1000 Thu 4/9/2009 12:48PM
Show -12 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
Johnny Thumps starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 12:55PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Johnny Thumps

jack_straw: OH MY GOD. are you serious?? that is truly outrageous, i love it - just gained a lot of respect for GD. that time of your life song is great too... phish should cover it.

phuc Thu 4/9/2009 12:58PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

phuc

My problem is not that they reviewed it, but that they wrote such a huge review, and we got nothing but a bunch of pictures on the JJ Cale review. Bullshit!

mockdaniels star Thu 4/9/2009 01:26PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

"they sell out stadiums, they're huge, biggest band on the planet." i read this website because USUALLY the writers understand that this is not the same thing as good music. see also: miley cyrus, jonas brothers.

rastarusty Thu 4/9/2009 01:32PM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

rastarusty

im not gonna lie i used to like green day. If you in to punk at all back in the day, they were pretty good. Then they started getting bad, and things just kept going downhill.

I like some old green day albums, but you couldnt pay me to see them now. They lost that up beat punk vibe, now its slow and trying to hard to be trendy or something. I wish they would have just stopped playing when i respected them.

its not really about music, its just doing anything they can to stay cool. and at least for me its def not working

pattyd908 Thu 4/9/2009 01:34PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

pattyd908

awesome! it's not jambase's reviews that started its downfall, its all the ignorance its fans have to offer. give it up folks, for all your negativity. peace and love.

rselover star Thu 4/9/2009 01:44PM
Show -7 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
Mr_McDankenstein Thu 4/9/2009 01:48PM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Mr_McDankenstein

The dose was running rampant at the independent

robbot Thu 4/9/2009 02:09PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Fuck green day. I saw an interview with the bass player and he said " we're the best band ever" thats fuckin lame

shanky95 star Thu 4/9/2009 02:19PM
Show -6 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
shanky95 starstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 02:35PM
Show -3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
phuc Thu 4/9/2009 02:50PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

phuc

Sorry shanky95...these guys were never punk. Don't insult punk by saying they were. That "shows how completely incompetent you are musically".

makelevees Thu 4/9/2009 03:05PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

makelevees

Hey Shanky95...who in the hell are "Jake and Marc"? I now have green day songs stuck in my head. Thanks.

whodoyoudo Thu 4/9/2009 03:30PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

whodoyoudo

woooooooo hoooooooo

moephishH2O starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 03:31PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

moephishH2O

shit, that would have been sick as fuck to catch them at the Independent. I remember when they kicked off Lollapalooza '94 and got the crowd hungry for Beastie Boys, Tribe, etc...

D-Line Thu 4/9/2009 04:09PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

jambase is on a downfall? really? seems like the same as it ever was. so what if they review greenday, who cares how long it is. relax closed minded hippies...everythings gonna be alright

Mr_McDankenstein Thu 4/9/2009 04:25PM
Show -5 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!
PooDolla Thu 4/9/2009 04:41PM
+3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

PooDolla

Good article Jambase!!! Don't listen to the narrow minded haters.

androckguitar starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 05:08PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

androckguitar

seriously, no need to hate...its cool that jambase covered this....Green Day is a good band, Dookie was a great album (one of the first i ever bought too)....yeah they are "mainstream" but for a "huge" band like that to play a show at the independent in SF (and i heard tickets were only 20 bucks!) says something, they still love to play music.

briank67 starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 05:22PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

briank67

to the haters, seriously, why even bother wasting your time here if you're just gonna post something negative? i'm not even a big fan but i applaud any 'big' band (and these guys are definitely big) for doing the occasional small/intimate show.

Henrock Thu 4/9/2009 05:24PM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Henrock

CORRECTION: Green Day USED to be a good band. They used to be a GREAT band! What they've become now....it's beyond disappointing. They used to be the closest thing to mainstream punk with the 'punk' part still intact, the music, the lyrics, everything. First of all, they (just like so many bands that used to be good) gave into what the label was telling them to do, which is wear fuckin makeup and develop an 'emo'-like style. Then, as much as I love bands that have a heavy political influence in their vocals, well they just changed their lyrical theme completely and yelled about the same shit that every aggressive band is doing now. They're just not good anymore, plus they attract the worthless My Chemical Romance kind of crowd

irtimed star Thu 4/9/2009 07:58PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

irtimed

"I'm also down for the unbelievable, genius, and heart-wrenching lyrics that are 'American Idiot'." Wow... I agree with what that song is about somewhat, but unbelivable? genius? heart-wrenching? If you're looking for that you should try Neil Young, Bob Dylan, or Robert Hunter. They're a punk band. And punk is just rock music that any idiot who knows 4 or 5 chords can do. And no, I don't only listen to jambands, and I don't think that jambase is going "downhill" because one yahoo posted an article about green day. they post articles about that shitty electronic music too.

Hotchkiss starstarstarstarstar Thu 4/9/2009 09:51PM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Hotchkiss

A little late here, but this is f*cking awesome (Green Day playing the independent, not a bunch of young, whiney little brats complaining. You little turds have been visiting jambase for a few years and you already think you know what is appropriate for them to cover. you are so damn cute!)

Like them or not, you can't deny their talent. They just got a lot cooler in my mind for doing this.

elaufer Thu 4/9/2009 10:43PM
+3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I'm gonna tell a green day story that I think illustrates really well how great a band they are . . . A few years back I was at the Bridge School Benefit at Shoreline amphitheater. For those of you who don't know, this is Neil Young's annual benefit for a special needs school where he gets serious hitters to do acoustic sets. The year I attended, some of the performers were Pearl Jam, Tom Waits, The Who, EmmyLou Harris, Neil Young of course, and yes . . Green Day. Everyone played great, but Green Day was absolutely incredible. Here's how incredible: my friends and I were walking out after the show marveling at how surprisingly good Green day was, when we were stopped by two old school, tie-dye wearing dead heads. And I mean old school as in Palo Alto days Grateful Dead. They had never heard of Green Day, nor any of their music before but were really impressed by how good they were, especially considering they shared the stage with Neil Young and The F*&cking Who that day. When you strip down a bands music to acoustic, you're left with the songs. And Green Day's songs held up that green day, appreciated by all . . . and those punk haters on this board, Suck On This!!!

elaufer Thu 4/9/2009 10:56PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

irtimed. Most of Dylan's songs only have 3 chords. That and the truth is all you need to write a great song. And besides, on guitar once you learn bar chords, you know all the chords. Neil Young is a fan of Green Day, see my post above^^^. But any idiot can write punk music, like Greg Graffin of Bad Religion with is Phd in Evolutionary Biology, or Dexter Holland of The Offspring with his Masters Degree, or Henry Rollins, yeah that guys real dumb.

schofizzl Fri 4/10/2009 01:10AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

schofizzl

i dont really care what jambase writes about and it doesnt really matter if i think green day is good or not... but when the fuck did billy joe armstrong start looking like a sad little asian girl? oh and i somewhat like the nostalgic aspect of green day, takes me back to my youth, but they did this little thing for the NCAA championships that was really fuckin lame... i mean really lame...

ski_bum_9684 starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/10/2009 07:16AM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

ski_bum_9684

Hey, why don't you haters all get together and decide on a list of bands that Jambase should be ALLOWED to cover and review? Not a serious request, but I'd like to see who you naysayers put on the list and leave off. How about Les Claypool? He's more alternative-rock than anything... guess he shouldn't be reviewed on Jambase either, by your logic.

If its music, and its good, I want to see it on Jambase. And if you have to hate Green Day that much... WHY ARE YOU READING THE ARTICLE?!?!

TheDude star Fri 4/10/2009 07:34AM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

TheDude

This guy "Troy Blanchard" joined Jambase yesterday? It looks to me like this is a PR person for Green Day and this whole show/event is a publicity stunt to promote their new album. I don't think even a fan would blow that much smoke up their favorite band's ass. They are just putting Green Day back in the public's eye before the new album comes out. Welcome to the music industry where nothing is for the fans, and everything is geared towards $$$. All I can hope is that they had to pay Jambase to put this shit on here...

Seriously...he compared Billy Joe to Pete Townshend...that is fucked up.

Smittea Fri 4/10/2009 09:51AM
+2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Smittea

Last time I saw these guys they were on the Simpsons.

Deadphishbiscuits Fri 4/10/2009 09:51AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Deadphishbiscuits

fuckin a right greenday bringing the thunder....those of you bitching...what have you done latley besides bitch on this site?

soulink starstarstarstarstar Fri 4/10/2009 01:10PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

soulink

Green Day played at DNA Lounge last night and the show might have even been better than this one. They played Basket Case!

Mark Price former NBA star Fri 4/10/2009 01:33PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Mark Price former NBA star

How many songs of theirs have the Jesus in the title?

vida421 starstarstarstarstar Sat 4/11/2009 06:42AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

vida421

I thought the jam scene was about having no boundries...whats with all the self-righteous a-holes who can't deal with hearing about other music...fxxk genres....and get of yourselves!!!!!!!!

spalla1 Sat 4/11/2009 09:50AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

good job noticing that the author has only been a member for a day. another thing that is funny are the bands he is a fan of. the dead, green day, wilco, and the black crowes........ i understand that green day was decent back in the day but they just dont seem to fit in there. i am all about different types of music but this is clearly just a stunt to advertise a bit more and try to not look like sell outs. saddly when you are in your late 30s (if not older) and eye liner you are past the point of salvation in my eyes.

spuduncadunc Sat 4/11/2009 11:55AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

i thought this was gonna be about earthday or something....anyone who says they didnt listen to dookie in middle school is a bold faced liar

Roos Sun 4/12/2009 09:23AM
-2 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I agree with Shanky95. I love these guys. If you dont.....why are you even reading this article....and why the hell post such negative comments anyway. GET A LIFE YOU NEGATIVE A$$ PEEPS!

guitardevil starstarstarstarstar Sun 4/12/2009 10:22AM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Here we go, first comment ever. I love green day. They've been doing their thing as long as Phish, and sans the hiatus'. But really, people are up in arms over this? How dare jambase cover a show in SF, where they are LOCATED! Green Day has done so much for me as a musician, and for so many other people. They have deserved to be covered by any website, any show, any time.

Hey, I love me some sound tribe, i love me some dead, I'll listen to anything. And today i'm going to love me some Green Day.

skatanic84 Sun 4/12/2009 07:29PM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

there is more music out there than panic, phish, the biscuits, yonder and umph.

jambase reports on music and for some of us, we like it ALL.

green day has been a pretty important band for some time now. they have changed for sure, they have money and aren't in their twenties. i support reviews that broaden the spectrum. plus that looks pretty sweet to see them in a place like the independent.

noreika823 Sun 4/12/2009 07:37PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

lame

JParadise star Mon 4/13/2009 04:45AM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

If this band was good, this would be good.

chancho Tue 4/14/2009 12:04PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

I own dookie and nimrod and i still listen to those albums but seriously that boulevard song and everything else i have heard since high school really kinda just blows. thanks green day for selling out.