The Whigs: Mission Control

  • View Comments
  • Send to a Friend

By: Shain Shapiro

I am torn by The Whigs' new record, Mission Control (ATO). In one sense, it is a ballsy excursion in plaintive, power-chord rock 'n' roll that remains consistent, heavy and energetic throughout. On the other hand, its monotonous song structure and unimaginative melodies are excruciatingly dull. On first listen, the 30-or-so minutes of music appear driven, straight-ahead and impressively conjunct, as college rock, alternative and Southern gumption combine effortlessly into songs that flow into one another almost blindly, as if their desire was to blend together into one distinctive whole. Then, after further listens, boredom sunk in and the sheer sameness of these songs dominated. Only "Mission Control," the last track and quite a journey, differs from the mold by using horns and dissonance to create something more substantive. The rest, depending on what you are listening for, is either a rollicking rock journey or another collection of songs that sounds like everything else. Regardless, this is the musical equivalent of a bare bones Honda Civic; some people like it plain because it has everything you need, but perhaps nothing you truly want.

JamBase | Athens
Go See Live Music!

http://www.thewhigs.com/

[Published on: 1/24/08]


 

Comments

snappy Fri 1/25/2008 10:15AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

snappy

Guess I fall on the side of those who dig it for its directness and smart simplicity. Sure, you can hear the influences (My Morning Jacket in particular comes through) but they're so unrelentingly into what they're doing that I'm pretty charmed. No wheels being reinvented but it rolls just fine.

johnnygoff starstarstarstar Fri 1/25/2008 03:46PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

johnnygoff

buy this album!

often debated, This album matches The Whigs' first albums' standards.

great stuff...wondering why the writer would say, "some people like it plain because it has everything you need, but perhaps nothing you truly want."

was Shain just trying to find a punchy, quippy conclusion because he can't be serious about this.

this album had a lot of what I truly wanted.

good album.

"

Mark Price former NBA star Thu 2/7/2008 08:45AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Mark Price former NBA star

The CD, is good not great, but good. I've seen those guys twice now, and each time hasn't sucked. The shows a kind of short, but they aren't a jamband, just good energy. If you have the time, and there in your area, check them out. DOn't let some article tell you what to think of them.

MaseBase starstarstarstarstar Wed 2/13/2008 04:53PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

MaseBase

I think this album is fantastic! I can see the points about monotony, and I am definitely not one for boring repetitive songs... but I think the songs and melodies win by far.