Spoon | 10.19.07 | Philly

  • View Comments
  • Send to a Friend

Words & Images by: Jake Krolick

Spoon :: 10.19.07 :: Electric Factory :: Philadelphia, PA

Britt Daniel :: 10.19 :: Philly
Chances are you have heard Spoon before. The band has coined a pocketful of licks instantly identifiable from soundtracks, commercials and a hearty stack of stellar albums. So why isn't Spoon bigger? They seem to have everything needed to break out and fly skyward. Yet, they've barely ascended over the last few years and their last few albums. Spoon writes songs with painstaking measures and they release progressive, thought-provoking records. Their songs have a calculated build but somehow manage to step off the main path and carefully touch aggravation and fear. Their just-below-the-mainstream-radar status landed them in front of a tame-yet-full Friday night Electric Factory crowd.

The performance started like a car on a sub-zero day. Eventually, after a few extra turns of the ignition and pumps of gas, the band warmed and sputtered to life. You could blame the tough start to not one, but two missing opening bands that forced Spoon to act as both warm-up and headliner. Even so, the band stepped up to deliver 24 songs and a pair of encores that spanned their last five albums. It was no small feat interpreting such a series of meticulous studio songs into a four-man show, plus horns, all in a glorified concrete crate.

Clearly, Spoon values their live show as much as their immaculately produced records. Britt Daniel was friendly, energetic and let loose touches of a greater stage presence. Jim Eno's drums dominated the reverberation of the Factory and retained much of their studio juiciness. Rob Pope's bass dipped and Eric Harvey's keys pounced into a few treats from Girls Can Tell and Gimme Fiction. "Fitted Shirt" was a crowd favorite and "I Summon You" was fantastic. The strips of LED lights synched with the beat of the songs, adding a slick element to the show. The couple of missteps were quickly noted and passed over by the band and crowd.

The mid-set grouping of Gimme Fiction's "My Mathematical Mind" and Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga's "The Ghost of You Lingers" offered a glimpse of what the band could really do. As Daniel moved the band from one of their most tightly wound pieces to an all-out guitar assault, his playing was greeted with frenzy over its formlessness. Both songs moved perfectly and stuck close to the album versions until they peaked. Then, with a shoulder spin away from the crowd, Daniel's guitar erupted into angst. Emulating Miles Davis by turning his back to the audience, the frontman dropped to his knees in a Jimi Hendrix style rock salute to his Vox stack. He struck the strings with a wild right hand, beating them into submission. He popped to his feet, heaving his guitar to the heavens and bowed down to finish. The moment stole words from the crowd but not audible cheers. It's well known that with Spoon there are no frivolous climaxes or abrupt changes in their sound. "The Ghost of You Lingers" live tossed that notion right out the door. It was unbelievably powerful, amazing and worth going to the show just to hear it alone.

Britt Daniel :: 10.19 :: Philly

So, why isn't Spoon bigger? Perhaps it's because they strive for the refinement of a recording while playing live. Aside from a few choice moments, they lacked much of the listless abandon of a performance by a road-tested band like My Morning Jacket or Jerry Joseph and the Jackmormons. Those bands are able to put the unscripted moment over studio sheen. This performance was like watching a Spoon album unfold. The effort and commitment was there, but also a lingering notion that Spoon lets their quest for perfection hold them back.

Watch Spoon Live at the Electric Factory

JamBase | Philadelphia
Go See Live Music!

http://www.spoontheband.com/

[Published on: 10/24/07]


 

Comments

JeffRad starstarstar Wed 10/24/2007 02:07PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

Interesting take, but luckily for Spoon, David Byrne, The Police, Arcade Fire and a zillion other bands, many audience members appreciate precision & the 'quest for perfection' as you put it. This review compliments the fact there are there are "no frivolous climaxes" than praises 'an all-out guitar assault' while begging for 'listless abandon'. That is not what all bands do... I doubt that is what is holding Spoon back.

As Luke Skywalker said, "I know there is good in you... let go". Or, stick with Raq & MMJ to satisfy your need for 'frenzy'....

mkgee starstarstarstarstar Wed 10/24/2007 02:27PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

They must have been saving up their juices for Saturday night in New York, which was an ILL show! They appeared to be really thrilled by (polite almost tentative) crowd. It was a blast. They did a really good job of mixing some older nuggets in with the new stuff. In all of the television performances, Britt's voice tended to be very treble heavy, but not on this night. He kept the lows and highs at a fine balance, and it was beautiful.

bigchris starstarstarstar Wed 10/24/2007 03:02PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

good review. I saw Spoon at the Treasure Island Music Fest and they were great. I enjoy them much more than MMJ, much better vocals and songwriting. They don't go crazy like some bands, but do rock out just fine. I see big things ahead for a group as talented as this.

aaronjl1 star Wed 10/24/2007 04:11PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

aaronjl1

wow, i never knew that every musician who turned their back to the crowd (especially in preparation for a rock slide) was emulating miles davis??? i've always heard that when miles turned his back to the crowd, it was to direct his band...

i don't know - maybe miles based his stage act around rock star pretensions- i'm no jazz expert...

toestothenose Wed 10/24/2007 04:42PM
+3 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

toestothenose

Folks much thanks for the comments and criticisms.

JeffRad - You took away what I was shooting for, but perhaps I could have conveyed in a different way. The fact that Spoon strives for perfection (and gains it) moved me in all the right ways, heck its one of the main reasons I dig them. Yet, Friday evening I was moved even more when Britt went off on the guitar differently then I have seen in the past. True not all bands need to push for listless abandon, but it produced the highlight of the show IMO. Hence the direction I took the review in.

Aaronjl1 – You also grabbed onto the Miles Davis reference (even if it was not too your liking.) Similar to you I’ve always heard that Miles turned his back to up the musical conversation w/ his band. That was the beauty of Friday’s unscripted moment. Britt spun and looked at Jim first, then Rob as Eric turned to face the semi circle Britt gave a great smile and went for it on his knees. - Sarcasm noted – Miles Davis was obviously not following in anyone’s footsteps, but simply adding a bit of pavement to the track for others to tread on latter.

aaronjl1 Wed 10/24/2007 06:40PM
+1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

aaronjl1

thanks,

"That was the beauty of Friday’s unscripted moment. Britt spun and looked at Jim first, then Rob as Eric turned to face the semi circle Britt gave a great smile and went for it on his knees"

really seems to capture the moment and clear things up for me.

also, at first i was questioning it, but now i'm looking foward to seeing them this weekend.

aaronjl1 Wed 10/24/2007 06:41PM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

aaronjl1

thanks,

"That was the beauty of Friday’s unscripted moment. Britt spun and looked at Jim first, then Rob as Eric turned to face the semi circle Britt gave a great smile and went for it on his knees"

really seems to capture the moment and clear things up for me.

also, at first i was questioning it, but now i'm looking foward to seeing them this weekend.

toestothenose Thu 10/25/2007 06:30AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

toestothenose

aaron - back at you - your comment and and Jeff's were perfect - they made me rethink my experience.

I should have mentioned why I focused on Britt spinning away from the audience. The Efac's stage is really high, so unless you were part of the folks standing directly above the stage you could'nt see what was going on,only hear it. It was almost as visually exciting as musically hence my reasoning for including the moment.

okalrightic Thu 10/25/2007 06:31AM
0 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

i saw spoon open for the shins on monday and I gotta say i was less than pleased with the show. i found it boring and kind of trite. i was actually looking forward to seeing them and now i have almost completely written them off. its cool that their music does it for some people though...

billywilke Thu 10/25/2007 09:40AM
-1 Votes Thumbs down! Thumbs up!

spoons boring